Sharks vs Oilers October 10: who gets the start in goal?
Worked a couple events at the Tank this week and heard a few things floating around the back corridors π€«
Word is the kid gets the crease on the 10th against Edmonton - they want the veteran rested for Boston at home on the 14th, and the pairings supposedly stay mostly intact from practice. Can't say more, you'll all find out soon enough. Against that Oilers attack (282 goals last year, they'll be rolling through town before Utah on their end), whoever starts better have his skates under him π
Screenshot this.
If that whisper is accurate, it maps onto the schedule almost perfectly. Boston at home on the 14th is the nastier assignment of the three, and a veteran usually earns his keep against a heavy forecheck like that. Giving him the Bruins date and handing Edmonton to the kid makes sense when you consider the Sharks conceded 292 goals last season, you're not winning a track meet with the Oilers anyway, so you might as well develop your goaltender against a team that will test him from every angle. Edmonton sits 14th with 282 scored, so the kid will see volume; treat it as a learning night with a low expectation of points.
One caveat, since I keep my own tables and I know how small these samples get: October Hockeyfights are noisy, and one start tells you very little about whether the kid is an answer. The pairings staying intact is the quiet news here, continuity in front of a young netminder matters more than the name on the crest.
I keep my own tables π
And if the kid gets shelled by Edmonton's 282-goal offence on the 10th, what then, ride him again against Boston two nights later because the plan says so? One whisper from a corridor and everyone's booking the rotation. Show me the numbers on how this kid has handled rest versus back-to-backs before I trust "the word is".
No daft question at all, Uncle_Guy, forecheck just means the team without the puck hunts it in the opponent's end, so Boston would pressure our defencemen the moment they touch it behind our own net, forcing rushed passes and turnovers. Think of it like a neighbour knocking on your door before you've even got your boots on. That's why a veteran who can skate out of trouble might get the nod against Boston on the 14th, while the kid faces Edmonton's offence on the 10th. A different problem entirely, more about surviving waves of attackers than escaping a corner π
Ben_Ultra explained that better than anything I read elsewhere, thanks π I only just learned what a forecheck actually is so this thread is teaching me loads π
Small worry though, if the kid gets thrown at Edmonton's 282-goal offence on the 10th and it goes sideways, wouldn't that dent his confidence right before Boston? Sorry if that's obvious, still learning this stuff π
GrampsFaithful1979 raises a fair worry, but I'd add a wrinkle to it: a kid getting shelled isn't always the confidence-killer people assume. What actually dents a young goalie is a vague role. If the room knows he starts the 10th so the veteran is fresh for Boston on the 14th, then Nashville away on the 16th, the plan itself becomes the safety net, bad game or not, he knows he's not being judged on one night against a team that put up 282 goals last season.
And honestly, when you count it properly, Edmonton finished 14th with 93 points and a 282-269 goal line - dangerous up front, sure, but they leak almost as much as they score, and San Jose's own 251-292 says the crease was leaky all year regardless of who stood in it. One rough start against McDavid's lot wouldn't move the needle on a team sitting 24th with 86 points.
I keep my own tables π
GrampsFaithful1979 raises a fair worry, but I'd add a wrinkle to it: a kid getting shelled isn't always the confidence-killer people assume. What actually dents a young goalie is a vague role. If the room knows he startsβ¦
@Gary_Legend this actually the smartest take in the whole thread imo π everyone's arguing confidence like a kid sees a 40-shot night and quits hockey. No, he sees the plan or he doesn't. JoshFaithful literally lived it and said the same thing and people still wanna debate. Clear the roles and nobody gets shelled into a crisis lol
It's a lottery, not sport.
That vague role point from Gary_Legend makes sense to me π my first year playing net, clear plan beat a quiet night every time. Maybe I'm wrong, but let the kid start. π
Ben_Ultra explained that better than anything I read elsewhere, thanks π I only just learned what a forecheck actually is so this thread is teaching me loads π
Small worry though, if the kid gets thrown at Edmonton's 282β¦
@JoshFaithful agree, kid should get the start. My only worry is the price. Books will still juice the Oilers moneyline either way, so I'll wait for the goalie confirmation before touching it. πΈ
Bankroll discipline wins.
Back in my day the old wisdom was simple: you never hand a rookie the ball when McDavid's crew rolls into town. But I've watched enough resets - sat through a few of our own in Calgary - and honestly that old rule died with the stand-up goalie. With a 251-292 goal line behind them, the kid's going to get shelled some nights no matter who's in front of him, so an Edmonton date isn't the scary test people think. Gary_Legend nailed it, clear role beats a soft matchup every time.
What I'd watch for is the surprise: managers love giving a veteran the Boston home date on the 14th as a "respect the fanbase" start, then quietly handing the kid Nashville away two days later. So the whisper about the 10th might be the true plan, or just cover for the real rotation. I'd say the kid starts against the Oilers and the vet draws Boston. But if the order flips, don't be shocked. We'll know by the morning skate π
Kid learns plenty watching McDavid pick apart a helpless backup from the bench too π Start him. Harry, waiting for confirmation? That's just paying extra juice for certainty, mate.
Show me your ROI first π
Start him. If the kid can't handle McDavid's crew in October, better to find out now than in a game that counts in March. Not convinced the "protect him" crowd has any evidence.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.