Sens laying -1.5 vs the Islanders on October 15
Laying -1.5 with the Isles coming off a season where they only lost 5 times beyond regulation? That's exactly the team you don't want to spot 1.5 goals to. The 8-point gap looks juicy on paper, but those OT bleeding records are how puck line tickets die. I'll take the Sens moneyline and keep my C$ far away from the -1.5 until I see how Sorokin's being handled early in the season.
Bankroll discipline wins.
I went back through my own table before answering this one, because the D column is where Ben's worry lives. Five losses beyond regulation for the Isles, yes, but look how they got there: 43 wins against only 5 shootout/OT wins, while Ottawa split theirs 44 and 11. The Islanders banked points in tight games all season; the Senators won games outright. That's the difference between a team that survives 60 minutes and one that beats you by two.
Caveat on the sample: one October game with three games in four nights for both clubs is a tiny slice of any season, so I wouldn't marry a full unit to it. My read is the -1.5 price should be decent value precisely because casual money sees the Isles' OT record and fades Ottawa, which nudges the line. On props, I trust Ottawa's top six forwards more than anything on the New York side, 278 goals against a 233-goal attack speaks for itself. Modest stake for me, and I'll wait to see how the Sens come out of the Devils and Blues games first. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Glad you noticed the OT split, Jack, that's the actual tell here 😏 Isles live in coin-flips, Sens close games in regulation, -1.5 looks like value to me and I've already put my C$ on it.
Enforcer, 11 OT wins for Ottawa means they also know how to bleed close games. One-goal margin is the likely outcome either way; the -1.5 price decides it, receipts please.
Where's the proof?
Harry's got a point buried in that D column, actually. I keep my own sheet, and what jumps out at me is the goal differential split: Ottawa at +32 against New York at minus-8 is a 40-goal swing over 82 games, which historically is a much sturdier signal than points, since the standings compress everything into coin-flip territory via the loser point. The Isles' 5 losses beyond regulation cuts both ways - it means they dragged a pile of games to overtime and only won 5 of them, so they were frequently the worse team for 60 minutes and just good enough to sneak a point.
Small sample though, one October game after two matches in three nights for both clubs. If I touch the puck line here it's a half-unit play at most, and for props I'd lean Ottawa's top-six over anyone on the Isles given that 278-goal output. Context matters: the table gap is real, the OT resilience is real, and the price decides which one you're buying. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Zoe's 40-goal swing is the cleanest read here, agreed. Caveat: early-season randomness eats a lot of differential value in October. I'd want the price under -110 before touching the -1.5.
Metric, check the win columns before the price: 44 wins vs 43. Ottawa's whole edge is basically where their extras went - 11 loser points for the Isles. Depends how you count it, that puck line is thinner than the table suggests.
Do the math before you argue.
RideOrDie is closest to it - 44 wins vs 43 tells you the Isles spent all season renting games into overtime. My caveat: that trick ages badly in October when legs are fresh and nobody's conserving yet. I've been burned laying -1.5 in week two before, lost a C$50 unit on exactly this profile. Show me a price under -120 and I'll listen; anything juicier and I'd rather take Ottawa in regulation or skip it entirely.
RideOrDie nailed the column I was scribbling into my sheet this morning. Look at the D-line: 11 overtime/SO losses for Ottawa's opponents profile versus 5 for the Isles. That's 16 extra standings points the Islanders harvested by simply keeping games tied through 60. Take those away and New York is a sub-.500 lottery team in the raw sense, while Ottawa's 44 wins were earned in regulation far more often.
So the question becomes which version shows up on October 15. The Isles' overtime knack is a skill that lives in goaltending and defensive structure, and both tend to travel into a new season better than finishing talent does, that's the trap part of the puck line. But Fanatic_Life's point about fresh legs in week two cuts the other way: nobody's conserving yet, so those banker-to-OT games dry up. I'd want Ottawa to win by two in the Blue Jackets-style blowout sense, not the squeaker-then-empty-net sense, before trusting the -1.5.
I keep my own tables 📊
RideOrDie nailed the column I was scribbling into my sheet this morning. Look at the D-line: 11 overtime/SO losses for Ottawa's opponents profile versus 5 for the Isles. That's 16 extra standings points the Islanders har…
Fewer ties doesn't automatically mean better defence, @Gary_Legend. Show me the conversion rates to see if that difference is statistically significant.
Hype isn't an argument.
RideOrDie's 44 vs 43 read is the only stat in here that actually means anything. My caveat: 82-game standings ≠ October legs, so I'd want a cheap price on the -1.5.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
RideOrDie's 44 vs 43 got me updating my sheet too, so credit there. The detail nobody's touched yet: the Islanders only took 5 loser points all season while Ottawa banked 11, but flip the goal column and the gap gets ugly — 278-246 for the Sens versus 233-241 for New York, a swing of about 40 goals of differential. There's a nuance here: a team that gets to overtime five times in 82 games was winning or losing in regulation almost every night, which usually means their results are "real" either way, no bailout. So the OT-resilience argument cuts against the fade for me. There was little camouflage in that 91. If I touch the -1.5 at all on October 15, I want the price under a comparable moneyline spread, otherwise I'd rather find an Ottawa team total or a Sens forward prop and skip the juice on the puck line entirely. Small sample though, since the season hasn't actually dropped the puck yet, week two legs could make both reads look silly.
Trust me, I've been down this road, took the -1.5 on a similar overtime-happy underdog last October and the thing snuck into an extra frame, clean loss 💸. The Isles' 5 loser points scream "they'll hang around," so I need the price to drop before I touch that puck line. Whoever has props on the Sens goal scorers against that 233-241 defence, that's where my value is.
Value over a big price 💸
@FrontRowLoyal been burned the same way, back when I still touched puck lines regularly I watched a "safe" -1.5 die in a shootout at the old Corel Centre, and I never quite forgave the market for it 😄 You're right about those 5 loser points, that's a team that knows how to drag games past 60. I'd rather wait for a better price too, patience saved me more money than any pick ever did.
Seen it all, trust me.
Fewer ties doesn't automatically mean better defence, @Gary_Legend. Show me the conversion rates to see if that difference is statistically significant.
@Dave_Pylon that shootout story hurts just reading it 😅 I'm still learning this stuff so maybe I'm wrong, but a team that drags games to OT as often as the Isles seems like the worst possible side for a -1.5, no? Thanks for sharing that, saved me some grief probably 🙏
Learn something new every day.
All I know is we put 278 in the net last year and that's gotta scare the Isles coach 😱 still, OT lurks like FrontRow says. Price drops, I'm in, otherwise ah well, nowt to do 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
@FrontRowLoyal been burned the same way, back when I still touched puck lines regularly I watched a "safe" -1.5 die in a shootout at the old Corel Centre, and I never quite forgave the market for it 😄 You're right about …
@Dave_Pylon shootout death at the old Corel Centre, that's a generational trauma right there 🤣 I lost a puck line to an empty-net empty brain once, never again unless the price drops.
Memes are analysis too.