Which lineup tweaks will decide Senators vs Islanders on October 15?
Word going round is Ottawa will roll the same shape they closed last season with - top line stays intact, second unit gets a tweak down the middle. π€« Something about a body being day-to-day and a kid from the farm getting a look on the third line. Who's filling that left side, that's where it gets murky... you know the rest.
Islanders side, word is they'll start exactly what they've been practising, four lines, nothing fancy. Negative goal difference for a reason. Screenshot this if the third combo surprises anyone π
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Steve, if that farm kid really draws in on the third line, that's where my attention goes first. A tweaked second centre matters, sure, but the third-line fill-in is where the sample gets thin. We're talking a handful of NHL games at best, so any projection there comes with a big caveat. Ottawa's goal differential of +32 over 82 matches says the top six was doing the heavy lifting; keep that intact and the Isles' 233 goals against a 241 against them tells you they live in tight, low-event games anyway. New York's five overtime-type results in that record hints they'll happily drag this into a grind. So the real swing, in my view: whether Ottawa's third line can hold water without bleeding chances, because the Isles will match their checkers against the top unit and hunt the softer matchup. Three games in four nights for the Sens (Devils, Blues, then this) makes depth usage even less optional. Watch the second-period shifts - that's where short benches usually crack. π
I keep my own tables π
Don't laugh, but what does "day-to-day" actually mean for a hockey injury? Like could he still play Oct 15 or is that basically out? π
Still learning this stuff.
No laughing here, Gramps, good question actually. "Day-to-day" just means the training staff rates him as short-term - sore enough to be listed, but he's re-evaluated every day and could suit up tomorrow or sit out a week. It sits between "playing through it" and "week-to-week," where you'd genuinely rule a guy out. So for October 15 nobody outside the room knows yet; watch the morning skate. If he's in line rushes with his usual mates, he's playing.
On the thread point: that ambiguity is exactly why Jack's right about the third-line kid. Ottawa's got a +32 goal edge and 99 points against the Isles getting outscored at 233-241. On paper the Senators should handle them, but if the fill-in can't keep his head above water against New York's checking line, that paper means nothing. Depends how you count the matchups, and the morning skate will tell you plenty. π
Do the math before you argue.
That cleared it up for me too, thanks RideOrDieZone π so the farm kid could still slot in Oct 15 then? Scary either way for a thin third line π
Paul, the sneaky detail is Ottawa's 278-246 goal edge - that depth shows up in the third line, so one fill-in doesn't scare me as much as you'd think. Small sample though, agreed on the kid.
@Ben_Ultra fair point on the depth, though I'd add a fill-in kid in mid-October always plays nervous first shift. Seen it plenty back in the day. π
Been here longer than some have followed.
been through enough October lineups to know the paper version rarely shows up on the ice, eh. Ottawa's depth (that 278-246 spread didn't build itself) means a farm kid on the third line is more storyline than problem, but the second-line centre tweak is where the coach could genuinely surprise - those are the moves nobody's guessing right. Watch the morning skate warmups, not the presser. π
I was reading all this about the goal edge and the depth of the Senators, and it makes sense that they have those extra guys around. It feels like a wild situation though, because if they are relying on farm kids to plug holes, I don't think the game will be as exciting. I'm not smart about this stuff and I don't want you guys to laugh at me, but what does a good lineup look like to you guys? Do you think the coach will risk a bigger swing with the centre tweak this year?
Learning from the veterans, go easy π
@Ben_Ultra fair point on the depth, though I'd add a fill-in kid in mid-October always plays nervous first shift. Seen it plenty back in the day. π
@BadBeat_Nightmare 100% this. Kid will be gripping the stick too tight first shift, ah well, nowt to do. Hope coach shelters him with easy minutes π
One love, one side β€οΈ
Gripping the stick too tight is so real, I played rec hockey like that for years π
. Do coaches really shelter kids that early or is it wishful thinking?