Blues sitting 22nd with a -27 goal diff
-27 goal diff on a team sitting 22nd, and folks still want to argue Blues +1.5? I put my money where the scoring is — Ottawa's putting up 278 goals, that's a side I'll back on the puck line or lean into their props instead. Saved myself the heartburn last spring chasing underdog pluses; bankroll is everything, so I'd rather lay the juice on a team that can actually bury it than hope St. Louis keeps it within one. 💸
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Jack's got a point actually, a -27 spread over 82 games can hide a few 6-1 nights that skew everything 🤡 but c'mon, 231 goals against Ottawa's 278? I looked at the Blues +1.5 on bookmaker and the price made me laugh, give me the Sens -1.5 or just take Brady/ Norris shots props instead. Waiting for the fanboys to pile in defending St. Louis...😂
Pedantically speaking, the -27 itself is a slightly lazy stat to lean on. There's a nuance here: goal diff over 82 games is one number, and it tells you nothing about how those goals were distributed - a couple of blowout losses can do the heavy lifting. With the sample so fresh in the season, I'd weight last season's scoring environment at Ottawa (278 for, 246 against) more than a static diff.
That said, I still agree with your conclusion, FaithfulFan63. Blues scoring 231 against a Sens side that finished 9th with 99 points, at home in Ottawa on the 13th, the +1.5 price will likely be juiced enough that the value is thin. I'd rather take a Senators skater shots prop than pay a tax on a puck line that most of the board has already priced in. Caveat: I keep my own table on these matchups, and one game before the Islanders visit on the 15th means rotation questions; worth checking lineups closer to puck drop. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Jack, a distribution argument cuts both ways - show me the numbers on how that -27 actually broke down before we excuse it. Enforcer, if the +1.5 price made you laugh, why were you looking at it at all? Ottawa at home on the 13th with 278 goals against a 231-goal side, then Jersey away two days later. I'd rather take the Sens shots props than touch either puck line without a price worth the risk. Not convinced anyone's found value here yet.
Fanatic's right that the distribution point needs numbers behind it, and I keep my own table every round precisely because of that, but with all three of Ottawa's games (New Jersey on the 12th, St. Louis on the 13th, the Islanders on the 15th) still unplayed, any split I'd show you would be from last season's sample anyway. Context matters there: a 278-goal attack against a defence that gave up 258 is the cleaner signal for me, and it points the same way Enforcer is leaning.
Where I'd push back slightly is the Sens -1.5 vs props question. I've been burned before by assuming a weak team just rolls over, especially one with 12 ties on the record, that Blues side grinds out close ones more often than the -27 suggests. Small sample though, and one game tells you almost nothing.
Context beats a bare stat.
Fanatic nailed it. Distribution claims without the game logs are just Jack's gut feeling wearing a spreadsheet. I'd want the actual breakdown: how many of those -27 came from three or four blowouts vs. a steady drip of one-goal losses. That's the difference between "Blues are bad" and "Blues are bad but keep games close," and only one of those makes +1.5 worth a look at all.
My caveat though: I'm with Enforcer on the lean, but the Sens' schedule is doing the arguing for us. Three games in four nights. New Jersey away on the 12th, then the Blues on the 13th, then the Islanders on the 15th. If Ottawa sits anyone in that middle game, the -1.5 gets shakier even against a team 47 points lighter. I'd rather take Brady shots than pay full juice on a puck line that depends on a full lineup. Staked C$50 on the props side last round, did fine without touching the handicap. Receipts please on that -27 breakdown, otherwise I'm not convinced the +1.5 deserves the mockery it's getting here.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Funny how everyone wants the game logs for St. Louis's -27, but nobody's asking the same question about Ottawa's 278. Depends how you count it, since a couple of garbage-time nights there would flatter the Sens too. There's a nuance here: 86 points from 37 wins is a team that loses close more than it gets blown out, and that's usually the profile that covers +1.5. Small sample though, so I'll wait to see the 10th against Columbus before touching anything on the 13th. 📊
Ben's point is fair, but it cuts the other way too - 278 doesn't tell you Ottawa's ceiling any more than -27 tells you St. Louis's floor. If we're demanding game logs for one team, we demand them for both. That said, I'll still side with FaithfulFan on direction: 278 scored vs 231, plus a 13-point gap in the table, that's the side I'd want my C$ on, just through props over the puck line. Small personal note: I stopped touching +1.5 lines after last season when I tracked every "safe" one I took for two months, the loss rate wasn't worth the juice, and that was with teams better than a 22nd-place side. Blues at Ottawa on the 13th? Define what "value" even means at a price like that before anyone defends it.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Agreed on demanding both sets of logs. My table has Ottawa's 278 spread pretty evenly, St. Louis's -27 lumpy, that asymmetry is exactly why I'd rather touch Sens props than Blues +1.5.
I keep my own tables 📊
Gary, "spread pretty evenly" pulled from where exactly? I'll believe it when I see the actual game logs, same standard everyone else is held to. That said, -27 lumpy or steady, I wouldn't touch Blues +1.5 in Ottawa on the 13th either - I'd rather put my C$ on Sens shots props and skip the puck line entirely.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Gary, "spread pretty evenly" pulled from where exactly? I'll believe it when I see the actual game logs, same standard everyone else is held to. That said, -27 lumpy or steady, I wouldn't touch Blues +1.5 in Ottawa on th…
@KevUltra2010 fair ask, I'd want the logs too before trusting any "spread evenly" claim. My angle is simpler, I priced Blues +1.5 at my Ontario book and the number had no value over laying the Sens moneyline instead, so it was an easy pass. -27 doesn't lie about a team that's leaking goals every third night. 🔥
Value over a big price 💸
@KevUltra2010 fair ask, I'd want the logs too before trusting any "spread evenly" claim. My angle is simpler, I priced Blues +1.5 at my Ontario book and the number had no value over laying the Sens moneyline instead, so …
@FrontRowLoyal everyone's a pricing genius until the Sens blow a lead in the third 🤡 laying the moneyline at those prices is how my C$ vanished last month, but sure, easy pass 😏
It's a lottery, not sport.
@KevUltra2010 fair ask, I'd want the logs too before trusting any "spread evenly" claim. My angle is simpler, I priced Blues +1.5 at my Ontario book and the number had no value over laying the Sens moneyline instead, so …
Does the perceived lack of value in that +1.5 make the whole thing a pass, even when facing a team like the Blues? Smart money knows that a mathematically unfavorable line is just dead money, regardless of how many odds you think they should be hitting. Trusting the book's pricing over your own hunch is disciplined play; bankroll is everything when you stick to that kind of logic.
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Fair ask for logs on both, Kev. My puck line C$ rode Ottawa numbers plenty of nights though, Blues +1.5 with that -27? Passed, and I sleep fine 💸
AmyZone has a point tbh, Sens blowing third period leads is basically tradition 😱 still wouldn't touch a -27 goal diff side tho. Ah well, nowt to do 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
nah man i watched the sens torch us at that HNIC matinee a bit back, still get flashbacks 😤 trustin them in the third? you just know the implosion's coming 🔥
You don't abandon your own.