Islanders host the Canucks on Oct 13. Who actually wins this one?
Two teams heading in opposite directions, and the table tells you most of it. Vancouver finished 32nd with 58 points and a 216-316 goal line - 100 goals against over the total, which usually means the defensive structure never showed up all year. The Isles sit 19th at 91 points, but there's a nuance here: they were outscored 233-241 across the season. A team with a negative goal differential at 91 points has been winning close games, and those results tend to regress.
For the moneyline, New York at home is the logical side, but I'd want a price better thanjuicy before touching it. My lean actually goes to the total, a leaky Vancouver defence visiting an Isles side that itself coughed up 241 goals screams goals. Caveat on sample size: these are full-season numbers, and opening-night rosters in October rarely resemble last year's stat line. Watch the period-one pace before piling in.
I keep my own tables 📊
Sort of like a grocery bill that keeps coming in over budget. That's what a minus-100 goal line looks like all season. Jack nailed it: Vancouver's defence never existed, and the Isles at least break even on the ledger (233-241, 91 points). My lean is the total over the moneyline; New York's -8 differential screams mediocrity at 19th, so I'd rather bet goals than trust either side. Small sample caution obviously applies until both teams show their October pace.
anyone else remember when these two used to really go at it, those early 80s playoff years? back in my day the Isles ended Vancouver's season more than once and the old barn used to shake. funny to think that rivalry's now a 19th vs 32nd mid-October matinee, but history's got a way of making Canucks fans here twitchy whenever Long Island shows up on the schedule 😉
Been here longer than some have followed.
Nah, my heart's with the Isles all day here 💪🔥 91 points against that Vancouver mess, minus-100 on goals is a horror show, they got shelled for over 300 goals! Backing them on the moneyline tbh, even though the outscoring thing (233-241) gives me the odd nervous moment.
BadBeat, the old barn still shakes when the crowd shows up, trust me 😱 Only downside I see is the Isles playing Tampa two nights before and Ottawa right after, if they're gassed, Vancouver might sneak the total over instead. But get in, New York all the way! 🙌
Moneyline screams Isles but 233-241 means they barely outscored their own mistakes all year, so I'd want a price better than -150 at bookmaker before touching it. Canucks gave up 316 and that defence doesn't get fixed over one summer, lean New York ML, small sprinkle on the puck line if it sits around +money. Motivation's on Long Island side too, home opener vibes. Landed for me in similar spots before, that's the play 💸
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
ChrisDiehard, that -150 threshold is where I'd anchor too, but here's my wrinkle: the total looks juicier than the side. Vancouver gave up 316 in 82 games — call it 3.85 against per night. And the Isles themselves finished minus-eight, so both ends of the ice leak. Depends how you count it, but a 216-goal offence against a defence that wasn't exactly a wall suggests goals, not a clean Isles win. Small sample though - October, both teams rolling out new pairings, goalies still finding their timing.
I keep my own tables 📊
3.85 against per night from last season decides October? Show me the numbers on who's actually in goal that night before anyone piles onto the over.
Fanatic has a point. Small sample though, but full season of 3.85 against is a big baseline. I'd still lean total, at least until the goalies for the 13th are confirmed. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Just relying on the full season's 3.85 against average feels like anchoring the prediction to weak data. What about their scoring output in the last ten games, or the type of defensive pressure they handle in that specific period of the schedule? Show me the numbers that back up the trend, not just the seasonal mean.
Just relying on the full season's 3.85 against average feels like anchoring the prediction to weak data. What about their scoring output in the last ten games, or the type of defensive pressure they handle in that specif…
@Metric_Hunter fair pushback, last ten games in early October mostly tells you about preseason form anyway. I'd weigh the confirmed goalie matchup first 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Been running my own spreadsheets on this one since the schedule dropped, and here's where I land. The merit case for New York is real: 91 points versus 58, and Vancouver bleeding 3.85 against per night over a full 82 games is not noise, that's a structural problem that rarely gets fixed by training camp alone. But ChrisDiehard nailed the caveat. A team that finished minus-eight doesn't get to be a heavy favourite, context matters with that 233-241 line. If the price is worse than -150 I'd pass on the moneyline entirely.
My verdict, for what it's worth: the total is the more defensible play, but only after goalie confirmations drop, which puts us waiting until the morning of the 13th at the earliest. Fanatic is right that last season's baselines decide nothing in October — ask anyone who backed Calgary in the Battle of Alberta off last year's numbers.
Do the math before you argue.
Just relying on the full season's 3.85 against average feels like anchoring the prediction to weak data. What about their scoring output in the last ten games, or the type of defensive pressure they handle in that specif…
@Metric_Hunter sorry if this is a daft question, but wouldn't the last ten games from early October be last season's games anyway? So preseason form basically. As a Canucks fan I'd love to say we surprise everyone, but 3.85 against scares me too 😅 Kev's point about the goalie matchup makes sense, no?
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Kev's got it right, goalie confirmation is where my money waits. I flamed out last playoffs betting a puck line the night before because the backup got the nod instead of the guy I priced in, cost me like 150 C$. Wait for the starter to be named, then I'll look at the number and decide if the Isles are worth it. 🔥