Enough tinkering - we need a proper top-six right winger
Word from a buddy who works around the league is a certain 30-goal RW might get shopped at the deadline if his team keeps sliding - and yes, the name made me spit my coffee. Put him next to Scheifele and Connor and this place would shake. Obviously pure speculation til it happens, but a guy can dream 😏
A buddy who works around the league, eh? Convenient how these sources always dry up the second someone asks for a name. Which 30-goal winger exactly? Team sliding how far, deadline why? Show me the numbers on any of it.
My accountant brain kicks in every time someone dangles "a certain player" with no cap hit, no team, nothing. If a real 30-goal RW got shopped, half the league bids and the price is a first plus a roster player. You think Chevy parts with that? Put a name out there and I'll happily run the cap math with you. Until then I file this one with the trade whispers about every star who ever slumped through February.
Now that's my kinda thread 🔥 we've been soft on the right side for years tbh, a 30-goal guy with Scheifele and Connor?? I'd lose my mind 🙌💪
Every year we do this dance, and every year the cap math kills the dream by February. A 30-goal RW who's actually available at the deadline usually comes with one of three tags: rental on an expiring deal (one playoff run, then he walks), a bad contract nobody wants, or a guy whose numbers are propped up by usage. There's a nuance here with the age too. If he's pushing 30, you're buying two prime years at most, and Chiarelli-style panic buys have burned this franchise before.
Depends how you count it, but realistically? A mid-round pick plus a B-level prospect gets you a rental, and I'd do that in a heartbeat if the internal analytics check out. Anything involving our first or a name prospect for a 30-year-old winger with term? Sample size matters. One strong half-season on a bad team tells you very little. Show me his shot quality trends without the power-play padding and his even-strength numbers, then we can talk dream lines.
I keep my own tables 📊
Fancy the rental tag doesn't scare me, Jack, pay the prospect, cheer him, let him walk. You all saw what Half turned down from Cheveldayoff for quick fixes, mate 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Millie's got a point about the rental tag, and honestly I'd pay a decent prospect for one proper playoff run, but who exactly is lining up here? Fanatic's right that a nameless 30-goal winger is just a rumour until somebody shows a source. Meanwhile we've been watching top-six tryouts on the right side for seasons while Chevrolet hoards picks.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Rental tag scares me zero tbh, we've got draft capital coming out our ears and this core's window is RIGHT NOW 🔥 I was a kid watching us waste Prime Scheifele years with AHL wingers on his right, not doing that again. Pay the prospect, worry about July in July 💪 ah well, nowt to do but dream
One love, one side ❤️
Glory, a "buddy around the league" has been the source of every rumour since forever. Name the team and I'll dust off the cap table.
Context beats a bare stat.
@ZoeTillIDie nameless buddy sources have killed more forum threads than actually bad takes. Show me the numbers, show me a team over the cap with a winger to move, and I'll consider the idea. Until then StandsGuy is spending draft picks on a ghost, no thanks.
Hype isn't an argument.
ha, heard this one before. back in my day every deadline had a "sure thing" winger that never showed his face here, remember the big name everyone swore was coming, ended up going to a division rival instead? zoe's right, show me a team and a number and i'll believe it. time will tell, it always does 😄
ValueDan's got a point, spending picks on a ghost is how you end up down bad. I've taken enough flyers in my time to know the feeling, loaded up on this one deadline deal I was convinced was done, source vanished and I was left holding nothing 😭
That said, StandsGuy's framing is right about the window. If there IS a real winger on a capped-out team, I'd rather pay a bit extra for the name attached than bet on a mystery rumour. Name the team and I'll tell you if it would've landed or not. Until then this is just forum weather. 🍺
Bankroll discipline wins.
ha, heard this one before. back in my day every deadline had a "sure thing" winger that never showed his face here, remember the big name everyone swore was coming, ended up going to a division rival instead? zoe's right…
@KevReds nah man the top-six RW hole is real, ghost source or not... how many more years we watching guys play out of position? 😤
You don't abandon your own.
back in the day we chased that same ghost at least twice a decade, young ones, and the pick we kept "saving" always hurt more than the hole it filled. andy's got a fair point about the out-of-position guys though, watched enough of that to last me. but a nameless source? i've got socks older than most of these rumours 😄
Seen it all, lads.
The discussion about needing a defined top-six RW is understandable given the current roster construction. However, I’m not convinced that focusing purely on filling a structural hole is the efficient path here. You need hard metrics on projected points per minute and offensive zone carrying success before you even begin looking at names, regardless of who else says the hole is real.
Where's the proof?
The discussion about needing a defined top-six RW is understandable given the current roster construction. However, I’m not convinced that focusing purely on filling a structural hole is the efficient path here. You need…
@LoonieHQ metrics this metrics that, meanwhile we've got a RW spot wearing a paper bag 😤 hard metrics on a guy who never plays? nah. You just know the out-of-position experiment burns us again in round one. Heart says it all, get a real top-six RW and stop analysis-paralysing it. Ah well, nowt to do 💪
One love, one side ❤️