Can the Habs stand pat at the deadline with 106 points?
Word going round the deadline room was the Habs would buy, and honestly with 48 wins and 106 points in the bank I get why the brass feels cozy standing pat. 283 goals for, sure, but 256 against is the part nobody at Centre Bell wants to talk about out loud. That's the half the story you keep hearing 🤫
Trust the core or add before the Canes roll in October 6? Those who know, know the cap picture is tighter than the table suggests. Screenshot this if you want, we'll see by Christmas 😏
Solid source, details in the DMs.
48 wins are fine, but the 256 against figure worries me. What concrete proof do we have that the current core holds up?
Hype isn't an argument.
FanaticArmy, fair question, and the honest answer is we don't have proof yet, only a direction. Here's how I read it. 48 wins in 82 games with a 27 goal positive differential tells you the core wins more often than it loses, but 256 against says the margin is thin. One bad stretch in April and that record looks different. My own tracking sheet has the Habs giving up high danger chances at a rate that would concern me if I were the GM, and no, I can't show you the underlying numbers because the sample in front of us is just the standings, nothing deeper.
So do they buy or stand pat? I'd say buy carefully. The October 6 opener against Carolina will tell us more in sixty minutes than a month of debate, and the home stretch against Nashville, Detroit and Buffalo right after gives us a real read on whether last season's structure held over the summer. Caveat as always, one week of hockey is a tiny sample, don't crown or bury anybody by Thanksgiving.
I keep my own tables 📊
Y'all gotta stop fixating on that goals against number for a sec. 48 wins means they're building something, and that core has the grit to handle whatever comes down the road. My heart says it all, and I believe in them through thick and thin, nah, we're gonna win this series 🔥💪.
On the terraces since I was a kid.
Jack_Fan said it well, 48 wins against a plus-27 differential reads like a team that wins tight more than it wins big. My caveat from keeping my own table all season: the against number didn't trend down after Christmas, it just held, and holding isn't the same as fixing. Trust the core? Depends how you count it, but I'd want the October 6 opener against Carolina to tell me more before anyone writes a cheque at the deadline.
I keep my own tables 📊
A defense that allows 256 goals isn't built for a long playoff run. Show me how that works.
The defence is a huge liability, I’ll give you that. But those 48 wins were earned in close contests, which matters more than big swings on paper.
Context beats a bare stat.
Zoe, sure, winning tight counts, on condition that you keep winning them in May too. Plus-27 over 82 games with 256 against tells me the margin is one cold goalie stretch from evaporating. The opener against Carolina on October 6 will say more about this core than any deadline room chatter, no?
Hype isn't an argument.
Dan's basically got it right, and my own spreadsheet says the same thing: that 256 against held steady all year instead of improving, which is the part that worries me. Small sample though, one game in October, but I'd still rather see a buyer's move before we hand Carolina a measuring-stick night at Centre Bell on October 6. Standing pat with a plus-27 feels like banking on a hot stretch repeating itself.
The fact remains that 48 wins mask a rather porous back end if you consider the 256 goals they concede across 82 games. One cannot simply dismiss that defensive vulnerability because they secured 106 points. I'll believe this core is ready for a deep playoff run once we have actual receipts from that October 6 game against the Hurricanes.
Where's the proof?
Zoe's got a point about the tight wins, though context matters, a team that keeps winning 3-2 nights is borrowing against its goalie. Ben's spreadsheet matches mine, 256 against holding flat all year is the tell for me. I keep a running goals-against column every round and the Habs line never bent downward. That plus-27 is real but thin, so buying before October 6 against Carolina feels like the safer play.
Do the math before you argue.
Nobody in this thread has mentioned the October 6 opener against Carolina yet as the actual test, which is the only date on the schedule that matters right now. 283 goals for says the offence carried the 106 points, fine, but I'd want to see how the back end handles a Hurricanes forecheck before anyone at Centre Bell writes a cheque. Receipts please, October 6.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Heard a whisper from someone down at Centre Bell that the cap room's tighter than folks think 🤫 All eyes on Carolina Oct 6, you'll all find out soon.
Screenshot this.
Nobody in this thread has mentioned the October 6 opener against Carolina yet as the actual test, which is the only date on the schedule that matters right now. 283 goals for says the offence carried the 106 points, fine…
@DaveBeliever one game in October tells you nothing about the back end, that's a lot of weight on a single night. Carolina will be a good measuring stick, sure, but if the D is still leaking by American Thanksgiving I'm done pretending.
Bettor angle for me is simple: a team giving up 256 a year and winning tight every night is a team whose puck line price never reflects the risk. I got burned on similar "great point total" squads before, took the ML because it "landed" all year, then the goalie regressed three weeks and the bankroll took the hit 💸 If they stand pat with that cap situation, I'm fading them against any half-decent offence after February. One date doesn't decide that, the market movement into the deadline does.
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
@DaveBeliever one game in October tells you nothing about the back end, that's a lot of weight on a single night. Carolina will be a good measuring stick, sure, but if the D is still leaking by American Thanksgiving I'm …
@FaithfulFan63 Thanksgiving cutoff makes more sense to me than one October night, agree there. My question is what "leaking" means, define it. High-danger chances against per game, or vibes? Because I watched this defence give up odd-man rushes all last spring and half the room called it fine. Give me the threshold and I'll take the bet.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Zoe's got a point about the tight wins, though context matters, a team that keeps winning 3-2 nights is borrowing against its goalie. Ben's spreadsheet matches mine, 256 against holding flat all year is the tell for me. …
@RideOrDieZone spot on about borrowing against the goalie, I lived that watching juniors, kid stood on his head for two months then the wheels came off 🔥 Thing is, 3-2 wins in April count the same as blowouts in November. You just know if the D leaks by American Thanksgiving though, FaithfulFan's right and standing pat looks real dumb 🍁
You don't abandon your own.