Hot take from your favourite forum uncle
Uncle's got a point and half of you know it π Two straight second-round exits while the top line piles up 55-plus points against everyone's backup goalies in November. Sure thing, mate, keep pretending regular season production means a thing when a real defence shows up π€‘πΈ
Which real defence shut them down exactly, Vegas? Name it, because two second-round exits isn't a sample size. Not convinced.
Y'all are way too quick to tear this team down over a couple of bad playoff games, tbh. That 55+ point production isn't fluff, it shows guys are playing elite hockey every single night! We gotta trust the talent and keep building on what works, instead of just panic mode after a tough exit. π Jets are gonna bounce back, no question. π₯
One love, one side β€οΈ
Fanatic_Life accidentally made the uncle's point for him. Two straight second-round exits IS a small sample, sure, and I've said that myself when people wanted Chevy's head after Colorado. But small sample cuts both ways: nobody's proven the top line can beat a committed playoff defence either, because the reps we have all ended the same way.
The 55-plus regular season points tell me the talent is real, Zamboni. What they don't tell me is whether it survives when a Vegas or a Dallas decides to sit on the line all series and take away the east-west game. That question only gets answered in May, and we've now got two Mays of the same answer. I'm not saying blow it up tomorrow, that's panic talking. I'm saying the burden of proof has shifted. One more spring where the regular season production evaporates against a real checking scheme and even I, spreadsheet guy, will be writing "sell at the peak" in the ledger π
I keep my own tables π
Seen this picture before, kids. Back in the day we tore our hair out over second-round exits too, and the old-timers said the same thing then, break it up, start over. Funny how the years you don't panic usually turn into the ones you're glad you kept the core together. Ask me again in year three of the rebuild π
Remember when the grass was greener π±
Sorting my spreadsheet by playoff rounds instead of points is always a humbling exercise π Did it last night with a coffee in hand and honestly the columns fight each other.
Here's where I land, sort of. ZamboniNation is right that 55-plus from the top line means they can play elite hockey for months. DaveArmy is right that panicking after Colorado nearly cost us patience we were glad to have. But neither column answers Fanatic_Life properly, because the honest question sits in between. Regular season production against depth pairings and backup goalies tells you a player's ceiling. Playoff attrition tells you whether that ceiling survives four rounds of a Vegas-style defence leaning on your best guys every shift. Small sample though, two exits, and I'd want to see one more spring before declaring anything. Ask me again after next April and I might finally pick a side.
I keep my own tables π