Honestly, trading a first-rounder for another defenceman beats
Watched Skinner's glove side get picked apart all playoffs and some of you want to "protect the picks" like they're a cheque under the mattress π Our 1st rounder isn't walking through the door to save a Game 6, another shutdown D could. But sure thing, mate, keep running McDavid 24 minutes until he drops dead on the ice π€‘
Show me your ROI first π
A shutdown D fixes Skinner's glove? Because that's what actually lost Game 6. I'd rather see a goalie answer before we ship a first for another body on the blue line. Receipts please on which playoff defenceman covered a leaky glove side, not convinced.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah Dave I can't sit with this one, we watched our D get walked through like traffic cones in Game 6 while Skinner hung out to dry π€ A shutdown guy hides the glove flaws, any half-decent scout will tell ya that. McDavid and Leon at 24 min a night again? We're begging for another first-round exit ah well, nowt to do π₯
One love, one side β€οΈ
Dave's got the sharper end of this, honestly. Context matters, a shutdown D can shore up the zone entries, but if Skinner's glove side stays soft, you've bought a better view of the same pucks going in. I'd rather see the goalie answer first, then spend the first on defence only if the blue line still grades out badly in October.
Do the math before you argue.
Been through enough rebuilds here to know a first-round pick buys you nothing certain. Skinner's the real worry, that glove side won't fix itself π
Seen it all, lads.
Dave's got my vote here, and I say that as the guy who tracks zone-exit percentages for fun. There's a nuance though: a shutdown D does cut the high-danger looks Skinner faces, so the two fixes aren't mutually exclusive, it just depends how you count it. My uncle ran a goalie school out of Saskatoon for twenty years and he'd tell you flat out that a soft glove doesn't get hidden by a better pair of defencemen, it gets exposed on the first bad rebound.
I keep my own tables π
Honestly both fixes need each other and nobody's said the number that decides it, what does a shutdown D cost in minutes against top-six competition? I keep my own tables and Skinner's high-danger looks ballooned once the pairings got scrambled in Game 6, so a body back there changes his math too. But if the glove stays soft, small sample or not, we're arguing over the size of the leak, not the ship. Where the first-rounder sits in this draft is the swing factor for me, and I haven't seen anyone price it yet.
Numbers > vibes.
Skinner's glove is leaking so bad I've seen better saves at my bar when someone drops a pint π€£ Trade the pick, then pray.
Memes are analysis too.