Honestly, this defence is good enough to win us a round
Honestly I'd take the defence over this forward group every day of the week and twice on Sunday. Sanderson and Chabot are out there eating 25+ a night like it's nothing while the top six apparently clocks out after the first period. Blame the blue line all you want, but you can't win rounds when nobody finishes a shift in the third.
I've seen enough of this movie. Wait for the fanboys to pile in telling me Timmy just needs more time, sure, and I've got a prop for you on us scoring more than one goal after the intermission 😂 I already priced this out at the book and the odds on "forwards go quiet again" were laughable really... because they're basically guaranteed 💸😏
Honestly I'd take the defence over this forward group every day of the week and twice on Sunday. Sanderson and Chabot are out there eating 25+ a night like it's nothing while the top six apparently clocks out after the f…
Two short sentences, then: "the defence is good enough" - you're both guessing. Show me a stretch where the top six actually got sheltered minutes; until then I'm not buying either half of that claim.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Honestly watching Sanderson eat 27 minutes a night and still close out games like it's nothing, I'll defend these guys till the end 😤🔥 GoTheDistance I hear ya but c'mon, that sheltered-minutes thing cuts both ways, you show me the forwards giving the D a single easy shift and THEN I'll take the guess argument. First period we look like money, second period everyone's a spectator, that's been the story for two seasons now tbh.
Chabot's out there on his heels every night saving us from the top six going quiet and people STILL wanna blame the back end?? 🤬 We make playoffs with this defence and watch it carry us a round... or the forwards ghost us again ah well, nowt to do 💪
One love, one side ❤️
I've been tracking this in my spreadsheets all season, and StandsGuy is onto something. Sample size caveat first: we're talking a partial season of game logs, so take it with a grain of salt. But when Sanderson and Chabot are both north of 25 minutes a night while the top six essentially disappears after period one, that tells you exactly where the coaching staff's trust lives.
Here's the nuance GoTheDistance is missing: the D isn't just surviving those minutes, they're closing out games with them. You don't hand a pair that kind of load unless the alternatives are failing you. And they are — watch the tape, the forwards stop driving play after the first intermission and every night it falls on the same two defencemen to bail out the structure. So yes, the back end is good enough to win a round 📊. The forwards? That's where my money worries live, and it's not even close.
I keep my own tables 📊
ah, this whole argument's got a familiar ring to it. back when Chara and Redden were chewing 28 minutes a night, folks swore the forwards were the problem too, and half those nights the D pair were the ones dragging the top six over the blue line 😄. seen it all before, good defence covers for quiet forwards for a round, maybe two. Jack's spreadsheet grain of salt note is fair, but GoTheDistance, give these kids the sheltered shifts and THEN judge em.
GoTheDistance asked for a stretch of sheltered minutes and nobody's produced one, which tells me something. I've said it before: gut feeling is just laziness with better PR. Where's the shift data? Where are the zone exit numbers for the top six after period one? Enforcer claims they clock out, Rob says the D drags them over the blue line. Pick one, because both can't be true.
Sanderson closing out games at 27 minutes is real, I'll grant that much. But "real" and "enough to win a round" are different claims, and so far the only evidence in this thread is vibes and a Chara anecdote from twenty years ago. Show me the numbers on second-period scoring by this forward group and I'll concede. Until then, not convinced either way.
Fanatic, I pull zone exit numbers for my own table every week and the drop-off after period one in the top six is real, though small sample caveats apply until we're 30-odd games deep. Rob's Chara-Redden memory rings true to me too: my dad used to complain about the exact same thing in '06, and half the time the forwards were fine, the D just carried everything. Chabot at 25+ minutes will do that to a lineup.
Context beats a bare stat.
Amy, "dead weight"? 😂 Those guys drag the top six over the line every night, I've watched it at CTC myself. And Zoe's already got exit numbers showing the drop-off, so how exactly is that laziness with PR? 30 games is nothing, we all remember how last season felt locked in by Christmas and then flipped 🔥
You don't abandon your own.
sam's got it right imo, i've sat in that barn through a few rebuilds and seen chabot carry whole periods on his back like this 😄 30 games is plenty for zoe's table to mean something, back in my day we had nothing but eyeballs and gut feeling. amy, watch the top six at ctc sometime around the second period before calling them dead weight.
Been here longer than some have followed.
BadBeat, gut feeling is what people say when they haven't checked Zoe's table. I'll side with the defence crowd on condition the top six shows up for 60 minutes, receipts please.
@MikeArmy fair ask tbh, receipts should come from the top six not the blueline tho 😤 our lot never make it easy but chabot and the D core have bailed out lazy forwards all year, ask anyone who's watched a full 60. heart says it all in round one, they show up or we're golfing early ah well, nowt to do 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
I don't really get the numbers but the D-core feels really strong to me. Are you guys watching them for a long time, because I'm still learning this! 🏒🤔
@SteveDiehard that's my read too, the blueline has been carrying way too much weight for the price of admission. From a betting side I always check the goalie and D before touching a total, and this core has bailed me out more nights than the forwards have. Round win though? Need the top six to show up or it doesn't land. 🍺
Value over a big price 💸
Zoe's table and 30 games is a decent chunk of evidence, though I'd still call it a small sample by playoff standards. My honest read: the defence holds up, but until the top six puts together a full 60 on a Hockey Night, nobody's got the receipts Mike wants. I'll keep my column open another ten games before picking a side.
I keep my own tables 📊
It’s like we’re arguing over the colour of the jerseys while watching the championship game, honestly. Someone just post a random play from tonight and let the numbers do the talking instead of us nerds fighting about what they mean. My brain is fried from sales calls anyway, so I'm gonna hibernate until the curtain call. 🤣😂🍿
Hold my pint.
It’s like we’re arguing over the colour of the jerseys while watching the championship game, honestly. Someone just post a random play from tonight and let the numbers do the talking instead of us nerds fighting about wh…
@RefBlindHater numbers doing the talking is how I lost C$300 on the puck line last spring, just saying 😂 but sure thing mate, drop the clip
I don't really get the numbers but the D-core feels really strong to me. Are you guys watching them for a long time, because I'm still learning this! 🏒🤔