Honestly, this defence is good enough to make the playoffs even if
Honestly I've stopped blaming the goalies, this blueline gives up so little clean looks that any NHL starter should look decent behind them. That night at Canadian Tire Centre with the 22 blocked shots and we still lost by one? That's on the guy in the crease letting in the two or three he absolutely should have had. Defence carried the whole evening and got nothing for it.
In reality the only way this group misses is if goaltending is a dumpster fire all year, and I'd even take that risk. Wait for the fanboys to pile in saying we need to trade picks for some overpriced starter 🤡💸 srsly though, I've taken Ottawa playoffs on the puck line futures already, defence is the part you can actually bank on 😏
Honestly I've stopped blaming the goalies, this blueline gives up so little clean looks that any NHL starter should look decent behind them. That night at Canadian Tire Centre with the 22 blocked shots and we still lost …
Any NHL starter should look decent? Which one, exactly, have we actually had behind this blueline? Show me the numbers.
22 blocks and still a one goal L, that's on the goalie sorry 😤 blueline did their job, back them all day 🔥
I keep a running sheet on this stuff and the 22-block night says blueline to me, not goalie. If you're blocking that volume, the shots that do get through are the desperation, traffic-screened kind, and one squeaking in for a one-goal loss is variance, not a keeper folding. I could be wrong, but Fanatic_Life has a point that our sample of starters behind this group is thin enough that "any NHL starter" is doing a lot of work in that sentence 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Back in the day you'd watch guys like Phillips sacrifice a body every shift and nobody whispered about the goalie. 22 blocks and a one-goal loss, that's hockey being cruel sometimes, not a keeper folding. Seen worse behind far better bluelines, trust me 😉
Rob, I love ya but I can't let that one slide 😄
Sacrificing a body every shift is noble, sure, but blocks are what defences do when the goalie's already been hung out a couple times that night. I remember a game in the old barn where we blocked everything in sight and still walked out grumpy, and the pattern was the same. The first fifteen shots get swallowed easy, so everyone piles up block stats, and then the ones that do leak through are screens and rebounds nobody can control. Fine. But a one-goal loss after THAT kind of defensive effort? A real starter steals you that game. Period. I've watched enough goalies here over the years to know when the blueline's carrying a guy and when the guy's letting the blueline down, and this looks a lot like the first one. Blueline's good enough, no argument from me there. But "good enough for playoffs with shaky goaltending" is how you finish ninth and spend April arguing about the puck line instead of watching hockey.
Seen it all, trust me.
Funny how both camps can look at the same game sheet and see two different culprits. Dave's got a point that heavy block counts can mean the keeper was already hung out, but my sheet from that night says most of the 22 were shot-blocking plays in the lane, first timing, not scramble rebounds off a leaky goalie. One squeaker through traffic deciding a one-goal game, that's variance more than anything.
Small sample though, one night doesn't settle the goalie vs. blueline question. What I'd want to know before picking a side is the split between clean looks and screened looks that actually got through, because that number decides who was really being tested. Until someone digs a bit deeper on that, I'm keeping this one open. Watch it again on Hockey Night in Canada replay if you can and count for yourselves. 📊
Do the math before you argue.