Can the last-place Predators really trip up the 106-point Canadiens?
Two months of telling my students to check their work before handing it in, and here I am double-checking my own table because Nashville at 23rd with 86 points just doesn't smell like a pushover to me. Yes, the Canadiens finished 6th on 106 points and outscored the Preds 283 to 247 last year, but that minus-22 goal difference for Nashville (247-269) tells you they were losing games tight, not getting run off the rink. A 38-10-34 record is a mediocre team, not a bad one.
My read: Montréal at the Bell Centre on October 8 should take this, depth and finish separate them over 60 minutes, but I'd be very careful with a puck line that assumes a blowout. Small sample though, since these are both first games of the season and neither side has shown us anything yet in the current campaign. The Canadiens then get Detroit, Buffalo and a trip to Washington in quick order, so expect some rotation thoughts hovering over this one too.
Context beats a bare stat.
Zoe, your table smells right to me, and here's why the gap looks scarier on paper than it plays. Yes, Montréal sits 6th with 106 points against Nashville's 86 at 23rd, and the 283 goals scored versus 247 backs that up. But there's a nuance in the records: 48-10-24 versus 38-10-34, Nashville lost only ten more games over 82 matches. That's one extra regulation loss every eight-plus games, which is the distance between a good team and a mediocre one, hardly a doormat.
The minus-22 goal difference is the genuine red flag for the Preds, though, 247 for, 269 against, and a road date in Ottawa on October 10 before this one doesn't exactly ease their landing. Montréal's schedule in front of the Bell Centre crowd (Detroit on the 10th, Buffalo on the 13th) gives them a rhythm Nashville won't have. Caveat as always: one October game is a tiny sample, and openers love embarrassing the favourites.
I keep my own tables 📊
anybody remember when nashville used to come into the old forum and just smother teams? i do 😄 these clubs don't have much of a bitter rivalry history honestly, but preds have always been the kind of awkward guest that ruins a home opener. montréal should win on paper with that 106-point season, but i've seen enough october games at the bell centre where the visiting team plays spoiler. careful with the puck line here, folks.
Been here longer than some have followed.
Went to a Habs opener at the Bell Centre years back, crowd nearly blew the roof off 😤 backing them all day, 4-2, and you just know the building gonna be LOUD 🏒🔥
You don't abandon your own.
Put C$50 on the Habs moneyline when the opener lines went up and the price never got better than -170ish, so I'm already in. Would Nashville have tripped them up? Possible, but I wouldn't have touched the upset, minus-22 goal difference on the road, opening night at the Bell Centre where that crowd is worth half a goal on its own. My call: Montréal wins it 4-2, and honestly the puck line at +1.5 for the Preds is the only value over a big price side of this market if you're not on the Habs flat. They've got Ottawa away and Vegas at home right after, so I don't see Barry's bunch coming into a building like that full throttle. Land it and my bankroll gets a nice opening-night top-up 🔥
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
JackBeliever, before you assume that C$50 is safe money, dig a bit deeper into how Nashville actually got to 86 points. A club can sit 23rd with a minus-22 goal difference and still be exactly the type of team that loses by one goal twenty times, which is the same as hanging around in the third period every night. My spreadsheet splits Montréal's 106 points into home and road splits every round, and openers at the Bell Centre have a way of inflating the favourite's price while the underdog just plays its structure.
That said, I'm still taking the Habs here, 4-3 territory rather than a cruise. The 283-247 gap in scoring is real, and Nashville gave up 269 to earn theirs. Small sample though, one game in October. If you want value instead of the moneyline, the puck line is where I'd look, because I expect this tighter than the table says. Then again, depends how you count it: points or process. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Gary, "loses by one goal twenty times" is exactly why the moneyline on the Habs at that price has no value, close games mean an underdog covering the puck line all night. Only caught Nashville live once in Saskatoon and they hung around till the last five minutes doing nothing. I'll wait for the confirmed starters before touching this, but Jack's C$50 looks like a donation right now 😭
Value over a big price 💸
My spreadsheet habit says look at the schedule before you look at the moneyline. Montréal hosts Detroit on the 10th, Buffalo on the 13th, then travels to Washington on the 14th, that's three games in six days before this one even settles, and Gary's point about Nashville hanging around in one-goal games is exactly the kind of matchup that punishes a tired home side.
FrontRowLoyal's puck line read feels right to me. Nashville's minus-22 looks ugly until you remember 86 points means they won 38 times; that's a team that knows how to keep games tight. I'd lean Habs to win at home, crowd noise or no crowd noise, but I wouldn't touch them at -170ish, and I'd want a cushion on any Montreal prop because a one-goal margin feels like the most likely shape here. Small sample though, one game in October tells us very little about either club's ceiling. 📊
Ben, the schedule cuts both ways, Nashville flies to Ottawa on the 10th too. Nobody's checking their work on that side 😭 Folding -170 was fine, on and forgotten.
My kid's hockey card binder has a rule: never pay full price for the shiny one. Same logic here. I'm with Retro on the schedule cutting both ways, but everyone's still pricing Montréal like last season's 106 points walks through the door on opening night. Keep in mind that the table you're buying at the ticket window is last year's model; the roster that shows up October 8 hasn't played a single counted game yet.
The number I keep circling is the shots-into-goals conversion, and context matters: 283 for versus 247 for sounds like a chasm until you notice Nashville was outscoring nobody by accident - 38 wins means they won their coin-flips more often than the minus-22 suggests they should have. A team that habitually drags games to a single-goal margin travels fine, and a fresh Predators squad arriving at the Bell Centre while the Habs are mid-cram for Detroit, Buffalo and Washington is exactly the profile of an upset opener.
Do the math before you argue.
Fair point, RideOrDieZone, but where exactly is the edge? Everyone in here is arguing price, and nobody's shown me why Nashville's minus-22 goal difference turns into a win at the Bell Centre. 106 points against 86, that gap is real. I'll take the Habs on merit, low confidence, and I'm not paying -170 for the privilege either.
My kid's hockey card binder has a rule: never pay full price for the shiny one. Same logic here. I'm with Retro on the schedule cutting both ways, but everyone's still pricing Montréal like last season's 106 points walks…
@RideOrDieZone love the card binder rule 😄 still learning this stuff but that makes sense to me. Paying full price for past points feels off, no?
@RideOrDieZone love the card binder rule 😄 still learning this stuff but that makes sense to me. Paying full price for past points feels off, no?
@Nick_Legend yeah exactly that, you got it 😄 last year's points mean squat once the puck drops, teams ain't the same roster to roster. Mind you I still can't see Nashville walking into the Bell Centre and stealing it... heart says Habs big 💪 but my wallet says wait for a better price 🔥
On the terraces since I was a kid.
@Nick_Legend yeah exactly that, you got it 😄 last year's points mean squat once the puck drops, teams ain't the same roster to roster. Mind you I still can't see Nashville walking into the Bell Centre and stealing it... …
@ChloeUltra the heart vs wallet split makes sense to me, maybe I'm wrong but I'd sit this one out too 😅 still learning this but the backup goalie thing ZamboniNation mentioned is what gets me, don't teams just look flat against a guy nobody scouted hard? Might just throw a few bucks on the Habs to win instead of the puck line, feels less painful if Nashville keeps it close 🙏
Learn something new every day.
@RideOrDieZone love the card binder rule 😄 still learning this stuff but that makes sense to me. Paying full price for past points feels off, no?
@Nick_Legend exactly, welcome to the club kid 🤣 I once paid full price for a "sure thing" and my wallet still files a grievance every payday 😂
Hold my pint.
gap's real alright, but minus-22 don't mean squat on a Tuesday night when the backup's in net 🔥 tbh I watched the Habs sleepwalk through a few home games this year, scary ones. ChloeUltra said it right, heart says Habs, wallet says chill 💪
One love, one side ❤️