Barkov is our greatest Panther ever, and it's not even close
Barkov does everything, wins two Cups and a Selke, and half this fanbase still chats about flashy scorers instead π sorry, but the quiet Finn is the greatest Panther ever and it's not remotely close. Fight me.
Show me your ROI first π
Greatest ever? Maybe. "Not remotely close"? That's where you lose me. Huugo was pulling 70-point seasons and two Selke nominations in this era too, and Luongo carried some genuinely awful rosters on his back for years - without him we don't even sniff those playoff gates in 2011-12. Barkov has the Cups, sure, but he had Tkachuk finishing and a proper defence corps in front of him.
So my question back at you: if Barkov had played for those early-2000s Panthers teams, does he win anything? Probably not, and does that make Luongo less valuable to THIS franchise? Not convinced it does. Two Cups and a Selke is a hell of a case, just stop acting like the conversation is settled before we've actually had it.
Luongo was unreal but he never lifted this franchise π Barkov got us TWO Cups and a Selke while doing the dirty work nobody claps for. CAPTAIN BARKOV π»π you just know it!
You don't abandon your own.
Luongo deserves his flowers, sure, but the sample tells the story: two Cups, a Selke, and the man still eating the hardest matchups every single night. Bobby Lou carried bad rosters, which is a different kind ofδΌε€§. Sorry, different kind of greatness - but you can't hand the crown to a goalie who never cleared the playoff gate here. Barkov is the standard, and honestly the gap widens the deeper you dig into the numbers. π
I keep my own tables π
funny thing, I watched the pre-Barkov years with the same season tickets I've got now. The endless rebuilds, the revolving door of coaches, and yeah, Bobby Lou stealing games we had no business being in. that 2011-12 run doesn't happen without him, and nobody here should pretend otherwise.
but here's what memory does to you: the guys who suffered through the lean years remember the goalies most, because they were the only hope some nights. Barkov is the reason that era ended. back in the day you'd trade your favourite player for picks and start over. Now the quiet Finn eats the toughest matchups every night and hangs banners. watch as long as I have and you'll get it: cups weigh more than great years on bad teams. Luongo's a legend of the franchise, but greatest ever? that's Sasha, and honestly I don't think it's as close as Fanatic_Life wants it to be π
Seen it all, lads.
Wait, people in here seriously ranking Luongo over Barkov? π Bobby Lou was great, sure, but one 2011-12 run vs two Cups and a Selke. Easiest read I've made all season. π
Am I the only one who thinks "greatest ever" needs more than two Cups the whole roster won? π
Love Barkov to death, but Selke voters love him more than highlight reels do, tbh. Luongo dragged trash rosters to playoffs single-handed - that's a harder carry imo π€·ββοΈ
had a season ticket through the years when our biggest name was whoever was on the cover of a program nobody kept, so forgive me if I chuckle at "two Cups the whole roster won." I watched this franchise before Barkov got here, back in my day we measured greatness by how early you could leave the barn without missing anything.
Here's my counter, friend: every great captain lifts the whole roster, that's the job. Gretzky had Messier and Kurri, do we dock him? Sakic had Foote and Forsberg. Barkov eats the toughest matchup every night, kills penalties, wins draws, and somehow makes the guys around him richer. That's what a carry actually looks like. Luongo stole games, absolute truth, and I'll buy him a pint any day. But a goalie can't drive play for sixty minutes. Two Cups, a Selke, and he still takes the least credit in the room, quietly, just like him. That's the greatest Panther, and us fans barely noticing is kind of the point of him π
Depends how you count it, honestly - I keep my own career-value table, and Barkov leads on cumulative impact, but Luongo's peak carry still tops any single season in franchise history. Dig a bit deeper and you'll find they're answering different questions. Small sample though, only two Cups in the books, so I'm leaving my ballot open for now. π
I keep my own tables π
Depends how you count it, honestly - I keep my own career-value table, and Barkov leads on cumulative impact, but Luongo's peak carry still tops any single season in franchise history. Dig a bit deeper and you'll find thβ¦
@Gary_Legend same split on my end, my spreadsheet has Barkov ahead on cumulative value but the single-season column is all Luongo, that 2010-ish carry was absurd. Depends how you count it, like you say. One wrinkle though, Barkov's defence ages like a fine wine while Luongo's peak was shorter, so give it another three years and the gap widens. Small sample of faith, maybe, but I'd bet a loonie on it.
Depends how you count it, honestly - I keep my own career-value table, and Barkov leads on cumulative impact, but Luongo's peak carry still tops any single season in franchise history. Dig a bit deeper and you'll find thβ¦
@Gary_Legend okay this actually helped it click for me π
so it's like career body of work vs best single season, two different questions. Still learning this stuff so go easy on me, but if I had to pick one face of the franchise I'd probably say Barkov since he did it all here. Luongo though, dragging bad rosters to playoffs? That's wild to think about. π
New here, soaking it up.
This thread actually taught me a lot, cheers π
maybe I'm wrong but I'd take Barkov too, feels weird picking a goalie as the face of a team. Go easy on me lol
Learning from the veterans, go easy π