A 93-point Oilers side sitting 14th still cracks my top five NHL teams
Funny thing about making a top five list when your favourite argument is a team sitting 14th, but here goes.
1. Oilers. 93 points and 41 wins in an 82-game sample is a good team hiding under a bad standing, and 282 goals for against 269 against means the offence carries them when it counts.
2. Whatever club finishes top three in the West standings, because point pace over 82 games beats my eye test every time and I keep the spreadsheet to prove it.
3. A division winner with home ice at a barn like Rogers Place quality venues, since playoff series get won on home starts.
4. Anyone who survived the brutal October grind, and that road trip through Anaheim, San Jose, Los Angeles and then Utah Mammoth on October 16 is a proper fitness test before Thanksgiving.
5. The wildcard with the best goal differential, because run differential is the one column that travels.
Caveat before the pitchforks, one season is a thin sample and standings lie more than shot counts do. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Funny thing about making a top five list when your favourite argument is a team sitting 14th, but here goes.
1. Oilers. 93 points and 41 wins in an 82-game sample is a good team hiding under a bad standing, and 282 goal…
Nah Jack, 14th in the league don't crack my top five, sorry bud 😤 282 goals is nice but 269 against?? That's leaking like a sieve... I'd put whoever actually defends first, Oilers maybe 6th or 7th for me. Offence doesn't win you playoff rounds alone 🔥
Seriously, skipping Connor completely shows you got zero idea what you're talking about 💸.
Millie's got a point, a team with Connor McDavid never skips the list. Watch as long as I have and you'll get it, 41 wins means they can defend enough when it counts. 😉
Seen it all, lads.
Market prices them like a 14th-place team and I've cashed puck line tickets all season because of it. 93 points at those odds is free money 🔥
Bankroll discipline wins.
Counting the votes in my spreadsheet (yes, I keep one for this thread 📊), the forum lands roughly on 1) Oilers, 2) whoever defends best, 3) the McDavid effect dragging them up a spot. UpsetKing's 6th or 7th is the lone dissent, Harry's tickets say the market agrees with the top-five crowd more than he admits. Small sample of voters though, and October will settle it starting with that Anaheim trip on the 8th.
I keep my own tables 📊
Harry cashing on the puck line doesn't prove they're a top-five team, it proves the market overcorrected. McDavid drags any roster up, sure, but 93 points is a mid-pack season and nobody's shown me the underlying numbers saying otherwise. Watch long enough and you learn veteran bias fades fast in the playoffs.
Hype isn't an argument.
FaithfulLoyal said it right. Cashed puck line tickets just means the odds were soft, not that they're elite. Show me goal share or 5v5 numbers before I buy top five.
Sample first, conclusions after.