93 points and 14th place says this roster is fine
Was at Rogers Place last spring and the building felt one piece short, if that makes sense π 93 points and 14th with 282 scored, that roster's closer than people think. My take, hold the cap space for the deadline, October 3 vs Seattle will tell us plenty. You'll all find out soon enough what I've heard π€«
Screenshot this.
"Closer than people think" based on what, a feeling in the building? A 13-goal differential at 14th place reads like a team that was fine, not good. I'd rather they save the cap space and show me the numbers by the October 3 game against Seattle before anyone starts shopping.
I was at Rogers Place when they dropped 8 on somebody two years back, still get chills π₯Ά 282 goals says the fire's there, hold the cap space and judge em after October 3 vs Seattle π€
You don't abandon your own.
The vibes-based roster management school is alive and well, I see π Look, I like the fire in your post, but a +13 differential over 82 games tells you the team outscored its problems more often than it solved them. 41 wins and 93 points, fine, that's a playoff-calibre floor. But 269 against at Rogers Place is the number I keep coming back to, and you don't fix goaltending against by holding cap space out of sentiment.
Here's the nuance though: Fanatic_Life has a point about sample size, one season is one season. My read is keep the powder dry until the deadline unless something falls in your lap cheap, because buying in early October usually means paying the panic premium. The October 3 opener against Seattle, then the road swing through Anaheim, San Jose and LA, will give us five real data points before anyone calls anyone. Judge after that. π
I keep my own tables π
Jack_Fan basically read my spreadsheet out loud, +13 over 82 games is a floor, not a foundation. I'd add one caveat though: 282 scored means the offence carried a defence that bled 269, and that split tends to get exposed in round one. Hold the cap space like Fanatic_Life says, but I'd keep it earmarked for a defensive piece at the deadline rather than anything before October 3 against Seattle. π
MikeArmy has a fair point actually, you can't fix 269 against without knowing which group bled them, and I keep my own tracking sheet so trust me when I say a single season is a small sample for defensive judgement π. I'd hold the cap space until the deadline too, especially with five straight October dates to learn from before touching anything. Remember the Habs winning a cup on structure more than stars, context matters.
Context beats a bare stat.
MikeArmy asking where the 269 came from and nobody answering is the whole thread in a nutshell. Save the cap space until we know.
Where's the proof?
HarryBeliever is right that we're arguing in circles, but the circle has a shape nobody wants to name. 269 against with a +13 differential over 82 games tells you the leak is systemic, not one pairing you can rent a fix for. I do this for a living, variance on defence across a single season is huge, and my own spreadsheet (yes, I keep one too, Zoe) says you treat one season's against-number as a floor question, not a blueprint.
My caveat to the "save the cap space" crowd: saving it is only smart if you know what you're saving it FOR. If we roll out October as-is and the Kraken game on the 3rd and that road swing through Anaheim, San Jose, LA expose the same soft spots, then deadline money spent on a stopgap is more expensive than cap space spent now on the right fit. Context matters, and right now the context is we haven't seen these five games yet. Wait for data before spending C$ anything.
Do the math before you argue.
Funny how 41 wins gets buried under the goals-against talk. +13 over 82 games is decent, hold the cap space and see what October tells us.
Metric_Hunter said hold the cap space and honestly that's the first post in this thread I'd put my name under. 41 wins gets treated like an accident around here, when a +13 differential over 82 games usually means a team one solid third pair away from being comfortable. My caveat, and RideOrDieZone will like this one, is that systemic leaks don't show up in the aggregate, they show up in November when you're playing the second night of a back-to-back and the same group gets cooked for four again. I track this stuff in a spreadsheet my brother in Calgary gives me grief about every Battle of Alberta week, and even my sheet can't tell you which unit bled the 269 without zone-exit data I don't have.
So my answer to the October 3 opener question, save the space, watch how the Kraken game and that road trip through Anaheim, San Jose and LA actually goes, then decide. A rental bought in panic costs more than one bought at the deadline, ask any accountant. π
I keep my own tables π
Gary, I'll believe it when I see it, but that's the first read here that fits the table. 41 wins and +13 after 82 games doesn't scream tear-up-the-roster, and a rental third pair in October usually costs more than the same guy at the deadline. Opening against Seattle on the 3rd gives us a free look at what we've actually got before anyone spends cap space.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Metric_Hunter and Gary got it right imo, +13 after 82 games ain't broken. My caveat: I said "we're fine" last year too and my fantasy team finished 14th π save the cap for the deadline πΏ
Hold my pint.
Every October opener here gets overread, remember last season? Five games in people wanted the GM fired. Wait until after Seattle on the 3rd, then judge.
Hype isn't an argument.
Word from a buddy inside the dressing room corridor is nothing big moves before Seattle on the 3rd, they like what they've got π€« 282 for, 269 against, that's a roster you patch at the deadline, not in October. Screenshot this if you want.
Screenshot this.
Word from a buddy inside the dressing room corridor is nothing big moves before Seattle on the 3rd, they like what they've got π€« 282 for, 269 against, that's a roster you patch at the deadline, not in October. Screenshotβ¦
@Montreal87 buddy inside the corridor, classic lol. But I'd take that bet at even odds either way, patching at the deadline is exactly how I'd play it too with 282 for and 269 against. October rentals are where you pay the stupid price, wait and see who's selling at the deadline. Saved me a few C$ hundred over the years betting that patience angle.
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
I really don't know much about deadlines or betting @JackBeliever, lol. It sounds like you've got a good system, though waiting until the last minute seems like the smarter way to play it. π
Learning from the veterans, go easy π