Who should start against the Jets on October 5?
Heard something at the rink last night about Sullivan's plan for Oct 5 π word is they'll start the usual top line against Winnipeg, but the third combo gets shuffled before that Dallas home game on the 10th. My source wouldn't say who guards the crease though... those who know, know π€« screenshot this if it lands.
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Steve, your "source wouldn't say", who guards the crease, who's actually nursing something on the third line? Because Sullivan shuffling that combo before Dallas smells like a injury cover more than a plan. Show me the names, otherwise this is just rink gossip dressed up as intel.
Steve, if your source wouldn't name the goalie then the "insider" is worth about as much as a warm beer π Anyway, the logic of the shape writes itself: Penguins sit 10th at 98 points with a plus-25 goal differential, so you start your top line against a Winnipeg side that went 35-12-35 with a minus-29, trust your strength, rest nobody yet. Save the shuffles for the Dallas home game on the 10th, since Chicago away and Colorado away follow quick and that's where depth matters.
I keep my own tables π
Sorry, dumb question maybe π
- when Fanatic_Life says someone's "nursing something", does that mean they're hiding an injury? Go easy on me π
Learning from the veterans, go easy π
No dumb question at all, Guy, everyone starts somewhere, and I'd rather explain it than watch you guess.
"Nursing something" just means a player is carrying a minor injury or knocks that haven't been officially announced - sore wrist, tweaked groin, whatever. Teams and coaches often keep it vague on purpose, so fans and opponents can't target the weakness. When Fanatic_Life says Sullivan shuffling the third combo before the Dallas game on Oct 10 "smells like injury cover," he means the lineup change might really be hiding the fact that somebody on that line is banged up, you dress the shuffles so nobody can tell who's actually hurt. Small sample though: until we see names or a lineup sheet, it's speculation either way, same as Steve's rink whisper about the crease.
Context matters here because Winnipeg sit 26th at 82 points while Pittsburgh carry 98 - on paper you'd roll the top line out with confidence on Oct 5, which is exactly why a quiet third-line shuffle raises eyebrows.
Context beats a bare stat.
Zoe, thanks for explaining that π so basically a guy plays through a knock without saying it. Still learning this stuff, don't laugh π
Learn something new every day.
DaveFaithful, you've got the right idea β the only caution I'd add is that "nursing something" can also mean Sullivan resting a guy as a precaution with the Jets on the 5th and Dallas, Chicago and Colorado stacked right after. Depends how you count it, but a 26th-place Winnipeg side at 82 points isn't the game you burn your third line in. Watch the morning skate lines on Oct 5, that tells you more than any whisper π
I keep my own tables π
π
@Gary_Legend, so if he rests them now, it's mostly to keep them fresh for those later games? Still learning how complicated the planning is. π
Learn something new every day.
π
@Gary_Legend, so if he rests them now, it's mostly to keep them fresh for those later games? Still learning how complicated the planning is. π
Nah @BethUltra, it's way more than just fresh legs, tbh. It's about making sure we can put out a fight in *every* game, not just trying to bank points now. Gotta keep 'em healthy for the whole stretch because one bad lineup later, we pay for it. πͺπ₯ We gotta play smart!
One love, one side β€οΈ
Nah @BethUltra, it's way more than just fresh legs, tbh. It's about making sure we can put out a fight in *every* game, not just trying to bank points now. Gotta keep 'em healthy for the whole stretch because one bad linβ¦
@StandsGuyFaithful I hear you, but my bankroll cares about who's between the pipes Oct 5, and a B-squad lineup against a 26th-place team moves that line way more than any fitness plan. I got burned last season backing a favourite that sat half its roster and lost outright, lesson paid for in full. Start the guys, bank the points, rest whoever you want vs Dallas.
Bankroll discipline wins.
Gary that explanation helped me too, thanks π So if I've got it right, a guy can look fine in warmups but be carrying a knock, or sometimes Sullivan just benches him to keep him fresh for the Jets on the 5th and that ugly stretch after with Dallas, Chicago and Colorado. That second one makes sense to me when I remember how coaches handled stuff back when I played house league in Oshawa π
Learn something new every day.
Gary and OG have it right, and here's the part that matters for me: with Colorado waiting on the 17th, I'd rest bodies against Winnipeg regardless of the standings gap. Same logic applies on their side, actually, Jets play Minnesota on the 14th and Chicago on the 16th, so neither bench wants to burn anyone on the 5th. π Small sample though, Steve's whisper could still flip by game day.
Ben's got half a point, but resting bodies against Winnipeg smells like overcoaching to me, I watched these clubs through plenty of Octobers and a 98-point side vs one sitting 26th is exactly when you bank the two points, then shuffle for Dallas. Sullivan's whisper plan (top line intact, third combo shuffled) reads realistic enough; where he'd surprise is pulling a goalie early in the week to have him fresh for that Colorado trip on the 17th. Mark my words, the real curveball comes after the Jets game, against the Stars π
Been here longer than some have followed.
Ben's got half a point, but resting bodies against Winnipeg smells like overcoaching to me, I watched these clubs through plenty of Octobers and a 98-point side vs one sitting 26th is exactly when you bank the two pointsβ¦
@DataDriven_Guy1992 early October is a terrible time to bank anything. Half the league is still finding its legs, Winnipeg included. Receipts please on the 98-point angle.
Where's the proof?
HarryBlues feel that pain tbh, sat a full squad myself once and watched the puck line torch me π€¬ I'd rather see our actual goalie in there, you just know he's gonna want this one π₯
In the stands since I was a kid.