Time to break up the Core Four, keeping Matthews, Marner
Six years of this core and exactly zero second rounds to show for it, but sure, run it back one more time and pray. Love the optimism, genuinely. π
And in reality? Marner is staring down free agency next summer and if he walks we get nothing but cap space and sad memories. That's a lottery ticket nobody should be holding. If some GM out there wants to pay a proper top-pair defenceman for him, you make that call before July and you don't hang up. Keeping all four together for year seven hoping the luck changes, laughable really. π€‘πΈ
Any stat can be bent.
Six years of this core and exactly zero second rounds to show for it, but sure, run it back one more time and pray. Love the optimism, genuinely. π
And in reality? Marner is staring down free agency next summer and if hβ¦
Define "nowhere." Two of those exits came without Matthews healthy, and shipping Marner in a panic before free agency is how you sell low.
Hype isn't an argument.
Man I've watched this movie too many times already π€ Sat there in 2021 when Montreal came back from 3-1 and swore I'd never feel that numb again, and here we are, same pain every May. JohnCalgary is right tbh, six years and zero second rounds, how many more "run it back" summers do we need before we admit it's dead?
FanaticArmy, selling low?? If he walks next July 1st for NOTHING that's the real fire sale, cap space and sad memories exactly like he said. Trade him now while every GM in the league knows he's a point-per-game winger and you might actually get a legit top-pair D out of it. Matthews and Willy can carry the offence, we've seen it. I'm backing a move all day, anything but another first-round exit with the same faces π
You don't abandon your own.
FanaticArmy has a point about selling low, but the sample says the opposite of "run it back". Six years, zero second rounds, and two of those exits with Matthews hurt, sure, but you can't hang every May on injury excuses. I keep my own table every round and the pattern is ugly whatever way you count it.
On Marner, my take is simpler than a panic trade. I'd rather get a proper top-pair defenceman now, with a year of control attached, than watch him walk next summer for a bag of cap space and sad memories. Small sample though, any trade return depends heavily on who's buying, so I wouldn't hand him to just anybody. I ran this past a buddy over coffee at Timmies and we landed on the same spot: this summer is the last window where you're trading an asset instead of a farewell tour.
I keep my own tables π
kids these days think this pain is new, eh. I sat through the Ballard years and the endless first-round stuffing by Boston back when the Gardens was still standing, so one second round in six would've felt like a parade to me π. but old man memories aside, JohnCalgary's got a point, if Marner walks for nothing next summer we'll all be quoting this thread in ten years saying we saw it coming.
Been keeping my spreadsheets on this core since the 2016 draft lottery, and even my tabs have stopped arguing with each other π. The honest answer is both camps are half right, selling Marner in a panic smells like 2021 logic, yet running it back a seventh May without touching the blue line feels worse. Sample size caveat aside, six years is enough that the question deserves a real answer before training camp, whatever that answer turns out to be.
I keep my own tables π
@Jack_Fan spreadsheets since 2016 and the conclusion is "both camps half right"? What's the tab actually saying about the blue line, though?
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.