Okay Knights fam, dream big
Man, this discussion about future wingers is pure dreamland stuff, kinda like checking the early odds before anything really happens. Word is Kelly McCrimmon has definitely been eyeing some names for the top-six, and I still think my ultimate longshot wish is getting Reilly Smith back. Wouldn't that reunion with the Golden Misfit be something? Imagine the vibe that would bring to the lineup.
"Word is"? Word from whom? Show me one credible source on McCrimmon eyeing wingers, because I'm not buying a Smith reunion off vibes alone.
Smith back in gold would make me lose my mind 🔥 the guy never stopped being Vegas Born, and our second line has been starving for a winger who actually finishes his checks and hits the net on the PP. Vibes or not I don't care, give me that reunion 😱 ah well, nowt to do but dream til deadline day
You don't abandon your own.
Fanatic_Life has a point about sources, so let me at least run the logic side of it. Smith is 34 now, which by itself isn't a dealbreaker for a top-six rental, but the question is what his game looks like in year whatever of the deal he's on. If he's still driving play at even strength and killing penalties, the fit is obvious: we've needed a dependable right-shot winger who doesn't disappear for stretches since, well, the day he left.
The realistic part is the cap and the ask. A rental on expiring money is exactly the kind of deal McCrimmon likes, since he's never been shy about moving a mid-round pick for a known quantity. The nuance is whether the acquiring team would rather move him at peak value or keep him for a push of their own, and that depends entirely on where they sit in the standings in February. Small sample alert on anyone quoting his recent numbers, by the way, a hot month can make a guy look ten years younger than the underlying data says.
I keep my own tables 📊
Fanatic_Life has a point about sources, so let me at least run the logic side of it. Smith is 34 now, which by itself isn't a dealbreaker for a top-six rental, but the question is what his game looks like in year whateve…
@Jack_Fan age alone never killed a rental, the skating did. I've burned enough moneyline tickets on aging wingers to know the current version is what you're paying for 💸
Gary, I love the passion but "hits the net on the PP" is doing a lot of heavy lifting there. Smith's power-play production has been sliding for a couple of seasons now, and Jack is right to ask what the current version looks like. Small sample though, so I'd want to see his last 20-25 games before anyone hands him a top-six slot on sentiment alone.
My honest worry is we're paying a nostalgia tax. The 2023 Cup roster lives rent-free in all our heads, but McCrimmon has to weigh cap space and what we'd give up in picks for a 34-year-old rental who might be a third-line fit at this stage. Context matters here. If the price is a fourth and a bubble prospect, fine, I'll drive him from the airport myself. If it's a second-rounder, I'd rather we chase a younger winger who actually fits the puck-line impact we need down the stretch. Dream responsibly, fam. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
YVR nailed it tbh, skating goes before age ever does 😅 we've all watched wingers who still looked fine on paper get eaten alive by a forecheck. if the current version of Smith can still keep pace we take him through thick and thin, if he can't, no rental saves that top six 🔥
You don't abandon your own.
Skating goes first, always. Watched my buddy's beer league winger decline the same way 😂 if Smith can still skate we're cooking, nah worries 🔥
You don't abandon your own.