Oilers sitting 14th with 93 points means the deadline is sell time
Was at Rogers Place for a few shifts last week and honestly the vibe in that building says it all. 93 points, 14th, plus-13 goal diff... that's a treading water team if I ever saw one. Word going round the corridors is moves get made before the deadline 🤫 screenshot this if you want.
Screenshot this.
Corridor word from a guy who watched shifts? Show me the numbers. 41 wins and plus-13 reads like keep swinging to me.
Nah, 41 wins and we're still 14th? That's treading water no matter how you dress it 🔥 sell the pieces that got us nowhere, keep swinging with the cap we free up 🙌
VeteranLegend, careful with 41 wins as a selling point. Thirty losses and a plus-13 over 82 games means the standings already priced this roster correctly, context matters. Sell the expiring pieces, keep the kids, and small sample warning aside I'd want cap flexibility before the October home date with Utah at Rogers Place.
Context beats a bare stat.
Zoe's got the sharpest read here. 41 wins and 93 points after 82 games just says mid, and that goal diff of 282-269 is barely a rounding error above average. Montreal87, "vibe in the building" isn't a source on that. If a buyer offers real cap relief for a piece, you take it, gut feeling doesn't pay the cap.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
If you spend enough time staring at the league table data, you start to feel like you're staring into the void, doesn't it? It's funny how easily people default to either 'sell' or 'swing' when the metrics are hovering right around the median. I gotta side with the general consensus that this roster, as constructed right now, is not flying. We're talking about 41 wins and 93 points sitting at 14th place; that's mathematically consistent with being merely adequate, nothing spectacular, nothing catastrophic. The goal differential of 282 to 269 simply reinforces that point, we're winning, sure, but the margin of victory is incredibly tight, and that's the definition of treading water.
The key, though, lies in the sample. Judging the entire fate of the franchise based only on the current eight-two record is premature. While it looks average, a team's value isn't just about past performance; it's about their potential relative to the competition in the stretch run.
I keep my own tables 📊
Jack_Fan, the median argument cuts both ways. Plus-13 after 82 games means selling buys nothing but picks. Show me a buyer paying for that.
Metric_Hunter nailed the buyer problem. Who pays real cost for a roster that ran 41-30 and finished plus-13 over 82 games? You're selling at the bottom of a flat market, and the return is going to be picks and nothing that moves the needle for years.
My caveat though, depends how you count it. That 282-269 isn't the same as a flat team, the wins column tells you they could close out games, so if a buyer wants a specific piece at a discount you listen. Small sample of deadline markets in my own tracking, but overpaying sellers of mid teams is where contenders blow cap space every spring. I keep my table the same way every round, pencil on a fresh sheet at my kitchen table, and the entry for this Edmonton club reads exactly like Montreal87 described the building. Treading water. Sell, but only on your terms.
I keep my own tables 📊
Gary_Legend, my caveat is that 41-30 with a plus-13 diff at Rogers Place sells low, but that's a seller's market problem, not a reason to keep swinging.
Hype isn't an argument.
FaithfulLoyal has it right in my ledger too. Selling low hurts, but 41-30 with plus-13 after 82 games at Rogers Place buys you futures, and I'd take picks over pretending. 📊
Selling low is one problem, but nobody's answered Metric_Hunter's question. A 41-30 team with a plus-13 differential isn't a package anyone overpays for, so the picks coming back are lottery tickets at best. I'd add one more wrinkle, whoever gets moved still has to fit under the cap next season, so "sell for space" only works if the space actually buys something. Receipts please on what that something is.
Where's the proof?
HarryBeliever has the sharpest read in here, honestly. A 41-30 club with a plus-13 differential over 82 games is the definition of fair market value, and nobody pays retail for fair. I'd take my picks and thank the buyer on the way out.
One caveat though, and it's the one I keep drilling into guys who ring me about my spreadsheets: a sell doesn't have to mean a fire sale. You move the expiring pieces and the guys whose next contract you can't justify, keep the core. I ran risk models for a living before I retired from caring about overtime losses, and the worst outcome is always paying full price for a coin flip. Selling low on scraps is a known cost you can budget. Swinging big from 14th with a goal difference of 282-269 is the move that sinks you for half a decade. context matters here, and the context says cap space plus picks beats pretending one more spring.
Do the math before you argue.
@RideOrDieZone I've sat through enough of these "sell at fair value" springs to know they never go the way the spreadsheet says. Back in the day I watched a club offload pieces at the deadline because the market looked soft, and half those guys came back to bite them for years. Fair value in February and fair value in June are two different animals anyway.
Supporter's got a point worth chewing on too. If buyers are only paying when they get desperate, then holding costs you nothing and selling costs you plenty. Beth, keep the hope, kid, it ages better than the hot takes do 😄
@RideOrDieZone I've sat through enough of these "sell at fair value" springs to know they never go the way the spreadsheet says. Back in the day I watched a club offload pieces at the deadline because the market looked s…
@Veteran_SinceDayOne 100% this 🙌 watched the same kinda fire sales gut clubs for years. Selling when the market's soft is how you end up paying double later, tbh. We're 31 goals up, why wave the white flag now?? Backing them all day 💪🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Question for RideOrDieZone though: if nobody pays retail for a 41-30 team, what exactly are we selling? You'd be moving UFAs from a roster that's 31 goals up over 82 games and hoping the lottery tickets land, meanwhile the dead cap space sits there doing nothing. I'd at least wait until teams start overpaying for insurance pieces closer to the deadline before shipping anyone out.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Supporter_TillIDie2000 asks the real question. Word from my source is nothing moves unless a buyer gets desperate, so we hold and watch 🤫 you know the rest.
Solid source, details in the DMs.
🤣 the "sell, sell, sell" crowd needs to touch grass. We're up 31 goals, I've watched this team break my heart enough without a fire sale too. Hold my pint and just chill, guys 😂
Memes are analysis too.