Makar is carrying this defence so hard that trading one of our
Makar playing 27+ a night so our second pair can donate shot attempts every shift is just great asset management π€‘ I'd move a top-six winger tomorrow for a legit 2D, Toews is fine as a 3rd pair guy with nice hair. Sorry, someone had to say it π
Any stat can be bent.
It seems like you've already got a strong opinion on the roster construction, but relying solely on minutes played isn't a complete picture of the situation. We'd need to see performance metrics on the zone exit efficiency and cycle success for that pairing before jumping to demanding a major trade splash.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah Toews is fine with Makar, the second pair is the problem π€ Been saying it since the Winnipeg series, we need a real 2D bad. GO AVS GO π
You don't abandon your own.
Funny thing, I was rewatching the Winnipeg series highlights on Saturday night instead of doing my spreadsheets, and honestly UpsetKing has it right. Watch the shifts where Toews skates with Makar, then watch the second pair's shifts back to back. The shot attempt swing is night and day. Paul, you're blaming the guy whose most common partner all season has been Makar himself. That's a partner bump you'd kill for.
So the odd man out question depends how you count it. If Toews is eating hard matchups with Makar and still holding water, then the fix is upgrading the second pair, not shuffling the top six to reach for a 2D who might just get fed to the same fire. I'd rather add a stay-at-home type for depth than gut the forward group over two pairings of noisy shot data. Small sample though, your mileage may vary, but I'm not selling a top-six winger in November. π
Watch as long as I have and you'll get it. Every team I've cheered for had one guy eating 27-28 minutes while everyone else hid behind him. Ray Bourque did it for years in Boston and I remember telling myself, thank god someone else wears that load. That was in the old barns, before anyone even counted shot attempts, you just watched the guy gasp through the third period and hoped.
The thing is, Bourque had a real second pair behind him most springs. Makar doesn't, and the Winnipeg shifts prove it, night and day like Ben said. So yeah, I'd listen on a top-six winger for a true 2D. Seen worse trades at the deadline, plenty of them. Just don't hand away the whole cupboard in February like some teams I won't name π
Been here longer than some have followed.
DataDriven_Guy1992 with the Bourque memory is exactly the point. Toews isn't the problem, never was. The question is which forward actually gets moved without gutting the scoring, and does the return cost us a first-rounder too. Who are you all eyeballing at the deadline?
DataDriven_Guy1992 with the Bourque memory is exactly the point. Toews isn't the problem, never was. The question is which forward actually gets moved without gutting the scoring, and does the return cost us a first-rounβ¦
@Fanatic_Life before anyone names forwards, define "gutting the scoring." Which version, 5v5 production or power play time? Those get traded differently.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
I only started following the Avs closely recently so maybe I'm wrong, but watching Makar log those huge minutes while the second pair wobbles reminds me of what Leafs fans always complain about. Still learning this stuff, does moving a winger even get you a defenceman good enough to lighten his load? π
Learn something new every day.