Makar is carrying this defence so hard that our second pair is
Fight me on this one fam, I'll wait. Makar's out there eating 27 a night and our second pair has drifted quietly into negative territory since that homestand at Ball Arena. Every shift they take at even strength I'm watching the other team cycle like it's a power play. And in reality? Bedard-era bottom six forwards are making them look silly.
I had the puck line favouring us last game and nearly lost my shirt because those two couldn't get out of their own zone. Laughable really. Meanwhile Cale drags the whole blue line up by the bootstraps like he's playing two positions. Anyone defending the second pair, go check the plus-minus and come back. 😏
Watching them cycle like a power play? Careful, that's gut feeling dressed up. Plus-minus drifts negative when matchups harden, show me the zone exits before I buy "liability".
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Zone exits?? Bro I've watched every home game this stretch and my eyes are bleeding, that's my evidence 😱
Kev you're right that plus-minus can lie with hard matchups, fine. But 27+ a night on Makar tells you everything, Bednar doesn't trust anyone else to eat those minutes unless he has to. Every cycle against our second pair feels like a power play against, no lie. I paid good money (like C$200 a ticket fam) to watch them get pinned in their own end for whole shifts.
Get in with the hype all you want, I still love this team 🔥 but nah, second pair needs help before the playoffs or Makar's gonna be running on fumes by round two. You just know it.
One love, one side ❤️
That 27-minute nightly load on Makar isn't just impressive play, it’s a massive commitment that inevitably drains the system. It looks like that second defensive pairing is really paying the price when their plus-minus starts dipping into negative numbers after the homestand at Ball Arena.
I keep my own tables 📊
You know, complaining about the defensive pairings always seems to be the easiest criticism to throw when things get tough. You see those numbers dip in a rough run, but remember how Jake Johansson played against the Canucks last year? He absorbed punishment and the team found ways to win anyway. We’ve seen teams go through this stretch before, they settle in and that whole system just tightens up.
Been here longer than some have followed.
Are we all just sitting back waiting for the cracks to show, or are we actually observing the pattern? I think Jack_Fan’s point holds up, for sure. When you look at Makar hitting 27 minutes a night, that load isn't just impressive hockey; it's physically grinding down the entire defensive shell. And when the secondary pairing starts coughing up negative plus-minus numbers like that after the homestand, the numbers tell the same story about system strain.
It's not just the seconds guys who are failing, though. They’re reacting to Makar being burned out. Think about the ice time correlation. When Makar has to spend so much time battling at the blue line, it forces the other guys to play deeper, clogging up the middle of the zone. Last Saturday night, for instance, I watched the second pair struggle badly in transition, looking like they were always three steps behind the offense. They’re drowning because the top end of the defence is trying to hold the entire structure up.
I keep my own tables 📊
Are we all just sitting back waiting for the cracks to show, or are we actually observing the pattern? I think Jack_Fan’s point holds up, for sure. When you look at Makar hitting 27 minutes a night, that load isn't just …
The 27 minutes a night is huge, @Gary_Legend. That kind of defensive wear makes the puck line riskier for me right now. 🔥
Bankroll discipline wins.
27 a night is a huge load tbh, nobody's arguing that 🔥 but blaming the second pair alone feels lazy ah well, nowt to do but wait for the coaching fix 💪
You don't abandon your own.
It’s genuinely frustrating watching the back end look so heavy lately. You look at Makar putting in twenty-seven minutes a night, and that’s not just volume; that’s a massive systemic tax on the entire defensive corps. That load management strategy puts an insane amount of pressure on the guys who aren't playing at peak availability, and that’s where the discussion needs to centre itself.
The dip in plus-minus for the second pair since the Ball Arena homestand, while certainly alarming, isn't always a pure competence issue. When you have a premier defender like Makar absorbing so much of the high-end possession time, it fundamentally changes how the other pairs are tasked. They aren't necessarily being outplayed; they might simply be operating under conditions of extreme fatigue or are being forced into roles they aren't built for in that specific tempo.
Context beats a bare stat.
I pull warehouse shifts and even my back complains less than the second pair rn 🤣 Makar playing 27 a night while everyone else just vibes 🍿