Makar is brilliant, but this defence wins nothing until we find a
25+ minutes a night for Toews in the playoffs while the second pairing got cooked every shift β and some of you still think the depth is "fine" π€‘ Makar can't play 30 minutes in May, he's human, barely. I'd laugh if it wasn't costing us rounds, but sure, keep panicking over nothing and I'll keep cashing the tickets against us π
It's a lottery, not sport.
Fifteen games of panic off one playoff run - I'll believe the sky is falling when I see a full season of that second pair.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
AmyZone lost her mind if she thinks we're cooked π€ Toews dragging 25+ mins means we NEED a partner, not that depth is fine. One deadline move fixes it. Ah well, nowt to do π₯
One love, one side β€οΈ
Kev's got a point about sample size, but fifteen games is a quarter of a regular season's worth of playoff hockey, that's not nothing. If the second pairing bled chances shift after shift while Toews soaked up 25+ minutes, the pattern is consistent enough that I'd want a real partner for him before we bet the prop on "depth is fine" and lose in round two again π
I keep my own tables π
been watching this team since the Foote and Blake days, one legit partner for your anchor makes the whole back end breathe. get the guy, deadline fixes plenty π
Every time I watched Toews kill a penalty alone in the playoffs I kept thinking the same thing: who exactly is resting this guy? Show me the numbers on what happened when Malgins or whoever drew in on the second pair. I'd bet the chance share against was ugly. Fifteen games might be a small sample, sure, but the front office doesn't need fifteen more to know a 2LD who can take pressure off Toews exists somewhere for a mid-round pick plus a spare part.
Kev, would you be comfortable rolling into another May with Toews eating 25+ again because "the sample was small"? I wouldn't. One deadline addition and this defence suddenly breathes, Makar gets easier matchups, Toews drops under 22, everyone's fresh when it matters. Not convinced the depth is fine, and I don't think the GM is either. He'll pay for a partner the moment the price is sane.
Rob's got it right, and Fanatic_Life, I actually keep a sheet tracking chance share against when the second pair was on. Ugly is a polite word for it. Toews at 25+ minutes in the playoffs is the tell: when your anchor logs that much, the coaching staff is telling you they trust nobody behind him. Same thing I saw from a press-box seat last spring, every time Malgins or whoever drew in, the cycle game in our end went sideways within two shifts.
One caveat from an accountant's brain, though: a deadline partner isn't free. That's a first plus a roster player leaving, and if the fit's wrong you've mortgaged the middle of the blue line for a rental who can't handle playoff pace. Ask Toronto how renting defenders has gone since 1993 for Canadian clubs chasing the Cup. Dig a bit deeper on who's actually available before we all assume "one move fixes it". But yeah, the need is real, small sample or not.
I keep my own tables π
Gary tracking chance share in a spreadsheet, my guy, that's commitment π but yeah he's right. Front office acting surprised every deadline like the second pair falling apart is new info π€‘
Nah, panicking tbh π
every contender's second pair gets cooked in May. Toews handling 25+ is a feature, not a crisis... ah well, nowt to do π₯
One love, one side β€οΈ
ah steve, i've heard this song before π every spring it's "every contender's second pair gets cooked" and every spring some team proves otherwise by actually having a third defenceman they trust. back in my day the old barns had guys eating 22 minutes on the second pair and nobody blinked, because there was someone behind them worth playing. when your anchor logs 25-plus night after night in may, that's a coaching staff holding a white flag, plain as day. toews handling it is grit, sure, i'll give you that, but calling a workload like that a "feature" is how franchises talk themselves into an early golf season. found a real partner for him at the deadline the way good teams do, and suddenly makar's not gasping come game six. seen it all before, friend. The panic is justified, trust me π
Been here longer than some have followed.
ah steve, i've heard this song before π every spring it's "every contender's second pair gets cooked" and every spring some team proves otherwise by actually having a third defenceman they trust. back in my day the old bβ¦
the old barns, they sure were hard on your back. still, some things are just as they've always been, regardless of the season.
Steve, that "every contender's second pair gets cooked" line falls apart the moment you watch tape of the teams that actually went deep, their coaches hid the weak pairing with matchups and Toews-style anchors behind them. Bednar had neither, so Toews ate 25+ and Makar got stretched. I'd concede the panic might be overdone, on condition that someone in the front office can name me a single defenceman on this roster they'd trust in a playoff second pair right now. Receipts please.
Where's the proof?
Harry's tape point is the right one. I tracked the shifts myself in my usual spreadsheet and Bednar never gave the second pair sheltered minutes, so Toews just absorbed everything. My caveat: even with better matchups, this roster still needs one more credible body on the left side, small sample or not. Speaking as someone who's watched from Quebec since the foil-era days, that deadline silence stung more than the series itself. π
I've tracked the same shifts Ben describes and the tell for me is that Toews never got a single soft matchup while the second pair soaked hard minutes, that's a usage problem and a depth problem at once, so small sample though it is, I can't fully buy either the panic or the "it's fine" camp. Context matters: which forwards draw in behind this group next season will decide whether we actually need a partner for Toews or just a sheltered third pair. Until then, count me undecided.
Context beats a bare stat.
Zoe nailed it, sheltering that second pair has to happen or Toews gets cooked again π© Bednar's gotta fix the usage... ah well, nowt to do
On the terraces since I was a kid.
Exactly this. I played D my whole minor hockey career, sheltered minutes or you drown, simple as. Give the second pair some easy shifts, fire Toews at the heavies π₯
Heart with the team, head on pause.