Second Whistle
Nov 22, 6:51 PM Log in Sign up
Colorado Avalanche

Makar is already the best defenceman in franchise history. Sorry

club debate Colorado Avalanche Fans Colorado Avalanche 10 posts ·108 views ·Posted: Oct 18, 2026, 2:00 AM ·Updated: Nov 9, 2026, 2:09 PM
EN Enforcer_YYZ Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 478 posts Oct 18, 2026, 2:00 AM
Hot take incoming and I'll die on this hill: Makar at 26 has already passed Bourque as the best defenceman this franchise has ever dressed. Downvote away, I've got room. And in reality? Ray was a machine, five Norrises in an Avs sweater is no joke, but the pace Cale is on right now, putting up points like a forward while actually defending, is something the 90s never saw. Different era, sure, goalies were worse, nobody cared about structure. Doesn't matter. Best I've ever watched in an Avalanche jersey and it's not close for anyone who's actually watched both. Wait for the fanboys to pile in telling me about 1996 😏
Reply Quote
FA Fanatic_Life Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 565 posts Oct 18, 2026, 2:44 AM
Twenty-six years old and already passed a guy who won five Norris trophies in this sweater? Bold. One good stretch of seasons and we're rewriting the record book? Bourque logged big minutes against the whole league for years here and took home that hardware repeatedly. Makar's current pace is spectacular, I'll grant you, and if he keeps it up for another decade the argument writes itself. But "already passed" requires the body of work, and that body isn't finished. Show me the numbers after he's carried this blue line through ten full seasons, then we'll talk. Not convinced yet, and I say that as someone who watches every shift.
Reply Quote
ST Steve_Fan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 133 posts Oct 18, 2026, 6:36 AM
nah I'm with ya, Makar skates like nobody we've ever seen back there 😱 five Norrises or not, Cale's peak is just different tbh. ah well, nowt to do 🔥
On the terraces since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
JA Jack_Fan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 1003 posts Oct 18, 2026, 7:15 AM
Gotta side with Fanatic_Life here, much as I love watching Cale do his thing. Bourque took home five Norris trophies wearing this sweater, and hardware over multiple years beats one brilliant peak until the sample catches up. Makar at 26 could absolutely get there, depends how you count longevity, but the record book needs more chapters first 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Reply Quote
DA DaveArmy Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 406 posts Oct 18, 2026, 9:43 AM
watched ray in the old barn and loved him to bits, but give cale another couple seasons and i might forgive myself for saying the kid's already ahead. patience 😉
Colorado Avalanche ice hockey action
Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
Reply Quote
HA HarryBeliever Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 151 posts Oct 18, 2026, 1:25 PM
I'll grant the peak is special, no argument there. But "best in franchise history" needs more than one brilliant run, and Bourque's five Norrises in this sweater are the receipts. If Cale keeps this pace for another four or five seasons, I'll sign the petition happily. Until then I'm not convinced.
Where's the proof?
Reply Quote
HarryBeliever wrote:
I'll grant the peak is special, no argument there. But "best in franchise history" needs more than one brilliant run, and Bourque's five Norrises in this sweater are the receipts. If Cale keeps this pace for another four…
PA Paul_Reds Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 50 posts Oct 31, 2026, 12:23 AM
@HarryBeliever nah mate, five Norrises is receipts alright, but I watched Cale skate through an entire playoff run like he owned the ice. Two cups in that sweater already too, Ray never got us one. Give the kid another year or two and there's no debate 🔥
Colorado Avalanche ice hockey game
On the terraces since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
Paul_Reds wrote:
@HarryBeliever nah mate, five Norrises is receipts alright, but I watched Cale skate through an entire playoff run like he owned the ice. Two cups in that sweater already too, Ray never got us one. Give the kid another y…
ST StandsGuyFaithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 559 posts Nov 9, 2026, 2:09 PM
@Paul_Reds two cups in the sweater counts for a lot tbh 🔥 watched that run live, he was unreal. Still gotta see a few more seasons from him though, ah well, nowt to do but enjoy
One love, one side ❤️
Reply Quote
GA Gary_Legend Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 396 posts Oct 18, 2026, 4:11 PM
Harry's got my vote here, and I keep a running spreadsheet on this exact question, which probably tells you everything about me. 👀 The five Norrises in an Avs sweater are the baseline, and Cale's current pace, as crazy as it's been, is still maybe three seasons of evidence against Ray's stack. Peak versus body of work, I'll take the body of work every time until the sample catches up. My caveat though: if Cale adds a second Norris or two over the next couple years, this debate flips fast, because his age curve means his best seasons might genuinely still be ahead. I saw Bourque at McNichols era replays growing up and thought nobody would ever skate the puck like that. Then I watched Makar exit his own zone under pressure last spring and had to revise my notes. Depends how you count it, but receipts beat vibes for now. Small sample though, ask me again in 2028.
I keep my own tables 📊
Reply Quote
BE Ben_Ultra Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 357 posts Oct 18, 2026, 5:55 PM
Funny, my old stats professor used to say never judge a career while the book's still open, and that's kind of where I land here. Cale's pace these last few seasons is the best I've charted from a blue liner, small sample though it is against Ray's five Norris stacks. Give it another couple of years and my spreadsheet might settle the argument on its own. Until then I'm happy to keep both names at the top of the page.
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.