Let's settle it, family: is Sid still our best centre
Geno winning more draws at PPG Paints this season and suddenly half of you are ready to hand him the C? π Sure thing mate, one solid stretch against Boston in the third and Sid's leaning on his wingman, by that logic I'm a betting god every time a prop hits. Sid's been carrying this club since before some of you could legally bet the puck line, eh. Laughable really π€‘πΈ
Show me your ROI first π
Millie, that Boston third period wasn't one stretch, Geno's been taking the tough defensive-zone draws all season while Sid matches up against top lines. Faceoff % is one stat though, who's driving play at even strength matters more, and I'd want to see Sid's minutes against quality competition before conceding anything. Happy to be wrong here, on condition that someone posts the actual zone-start and matchup numbers instead of vibes.
Hype isn't an argument.
Watched Sid save our season too many times to count tbh π€ Geno taking tough draws don't change who the captain is. We ride with 87, through thick and thin ππ€
On the terraces since I was a kid.
Millie's got a point buried in the sarcasm, though. One third period against Boston is a smaller sample than my Grade 9 attendance records π. What actually matters is that Geno's home faceoff numbers have been quietly better than Sid's all season at PPG Paints. That's a pattern, one game just happened to be where people noticed.
Here's my two-step way of reading it: first, ValueDan is right that the usage matters more than raw percentage, since Geno's eating the defensive-zone draws while Sid handles top-line matchups; second, "best centre" and "who takes the clutch draw" are two different questions. I've taught enough math to know a fifty-game trend beats one highlight reel, but I also know the torch question doesn't get settled by faceoffs alone. Both guys get their flowers from me.
Context beats a bare stat.
goodness, the faceoff debates never change do they π back in the day we had the same argument about who really ran the draws, and my old man used to say a centre is judged by what happens after the puck drops, not at it. watched this team long enough to know both these guys have carried stretches where the other leaned on them. genos home numbers being better this season? fine, credit where its due, value dan is right that the tough d-zone draws matter. but watch as long as I have and you'll get it, the torch talk comes up every year about this time, and every year sid answers it on the ice. let the season settle it, not one boston third.
Seen it all, lads.
Ha, my old man said the same thing about Bob Gainey's draws, dad, and Sid's been winning games after the puck drops for two decades π
Been here longer than some have followed.
BadBeatPTSD's dad had it right. What happens after the draw matters - show me the numbers on Geno's zone exits, and then we'll talk. Not convinced by one Boston period.
Fanatic_Life, agreed on the zone exits, I keep my own table on that every round and Geno's been fine, though the caveat is a two-week sample, which is barely enough to tell you anything about a player's trend. Still got Sid's faceoff sheet from the Boston game printed in my folder here in Regina, and honestly the captain deferΒring on those late third-period draws reads more like trust than decline. Depends how you count it, but I'd still say the torch hasn't moved.
I keep my own tables π
Funny thing, my kid asked me last night who the best centre in the house is and I gave him the same answer I'll give you lot: depends how you count it. π
I keep my own draw sheet every round, and yes, Geno's home percentage this season has crept past Sid's, and the third-period work against Boston was real, I charted it myself. But Jack_Fan's caveat is the right one - two weeks of zone exits and a couple of hot periods at PPG Paints is a window, not a trend. Sid's value has never lived entirely in the dot anyway; it's the D-zone assignments, the matchup minutes, the stuff that doesn't fit neatly in a column. My honest read: the gap between them on home ice has narrowed enough that the question is worth asking, which is more than I could've said last spring. Ask me again after twenty more games and I might actually answer it.
Do the math before you argue.
Funny thing, my kid asked me last night who the best centre in the house is and I gave him the same answer I'll give you lot: depends how you count it. π
I keep my own draw sheet every round, and yes, Geno's home percenβ¦
@RideOrDieZone depends how you count it?? nah man... heart says Sid, always. Watched him my whole life, not turning now π₯πͺ backing him all day tbh
Funny thing, my kid asked me last night who the best centre in the house is and I gave him the same answer I'll give you lot: depends how you count it. π
I keep my own draw sheet every round, and yes, Geno's home percenβ¦
Sid is THE best man, always. Stats don't define greatness anyway. π₯π― Get in!
One love, one side β€οΈ
Bit of a newbie question here, but when you two say zone exits, do you mean like how the team gets the puck out of their own end when Geno's on the ice? π€ still learning this stuff, sorry if it's obvious. My uncle in Hamilton swears Sid's the best no matter what the numbers say π
Learn something new every day.