Honest take, fam: this defence without Pietro is more fun to watch
Honest take? I'll take the current D-core over the 2023 wall any night of the week, and I watched that Cup run from a bar stool sweating every clearance. Back then it was block, block, scramble, repeat. Now the breakout actually moves and the crowd sounds alive again instead of holding its breath.
I remember the meltdown posts when we moved a piece of that blue line, half this forum ready to light candles. And now? Same folk quietly enjoying stretch passes and chanting Vee-gas like nothing happened. I put a little on the puck line in the home opener specifically because our defence moves the puck faster than the other team can line up, and that's the whole difference. Anyone pining for the old shot-blocking wall, meet me in the lounge and bring your shoulder pads 😏
It's a lottery, not sport.
Honest take? I'll take the current D-core over the 2023 wall any night of the week, and I watched that Cup run from a bar stool sweating every clearance. Back then it was block, block, scramble, repeat. Now the breakout …
Fun while it lasted, AmyZone, but I watched that 2023 run with my own eyes and the wall is what won it. Defence wins playoffs. Show me this D-core surviving four rounds of forecheck pressure without Pietro and I'll listen. Until then I'm not convinced the atmosphere at T-Mobile matters more than the results.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Four rounds of forecheck? We SKATED through that D last spring tbh 🔥 Fun beats bruising every night, Backcheck. Vee-gas louder than ever, come at me 😤💪
One love, one side ❤️
Gonna side with AmyZone here, with the usual caveat that a full season is a bigger sample than a hot spring. Backcheck's "defence wins playoffs" line holds up over four rounds, sure, but the 2023 wall won by strangling games 2-1 while we all aged a decade per clearance. This group moves the puck before the forecheck sets, and I'd rather bet on puck movement than shot-blocking alone keeping up with today's speed. Ask me again in round two and I might flip, but for watching purposes? No contest.
I keep my own tables 📊
I was at a watch party the night we lifted that Cup and I still remember gripping my beer through every late clear like it was game 7 of a war. That wall was beautiful in its own grim way, I'll give Backcheck that much. You block, you survive, you breathe again. Old school hockey at its finest.
But here's my two cents after a few decades of this: the teams I loved most weren't the ones that made me hold my breath, they were the ones that made me stand up. This group moving the puck like that, with the barn loud the whole way? Jack_Fan nailed it, aging a decade per clearance isn't my idea of fun. Defence still wins playoffs, sure, but there's more than one way to defend. Ask anybody who's tried forechecking a breakout that actually moves 😉
Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
RobLegend's got a point, honestly. My spreadsheets say the new breakout is prettier, but I filed my 2023 stress as entertainment too 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Funny thing about my own tables, I stopped filing the 2023 games under "stress" and started filing them under "cardio." Gary's right that the breakout is prettier, but Rob's receipts question is fair, one hot stretch of zone exits tells you less than four rounds of bodies in front of the net. Depends how you count it, honestly. If fun per minute is the metric, the current group wins walking away. If late leads defended in May are the metric, the old wall still owns that ledger. My puck line bets this spring have me leaning pretty, but my ulcers from that Cup run lean grim. Ask me again after round three.
Do the math before you argue.
RobLegend's got a point, honestly. My spreadsheets say the new breakout is prettier, but I filed my 2023 stress as entertainment too 📊
Do the analysts ever look past the spreadsheet and see the actual risk profile of the defence? How many times has a pretty breakout system collapsed in a high-stakes series? I always track the puck line, not the aesthetics of the play. If the new system generates higher ROI for us on the market, that's the only data point that matters.
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Do the analysts ever look past the spreadsheet and see the actual risk profile of the defence? How many times has a pretty breakout system collapsed in a high-stakes series? I always track the puck line, not the aestheti…
@ChrisDiehard for real though. Spreadsheets never show you the absolute grind or the sheer risk they take for us... you've hit the nail on the head. It's about the bodies and the puck line, not some pretty breakout diagram that looks good on paper but doesn't hold up when the pressure hits, tbh.
In the stands since I was a kid.