Honest question, fam: is this defence actually good enough for a Cup
Honest answer? No, the defence isn't good enough, and half this fanbase knows it but keeps hoping Rielly figures it out by April. He's fine as a second-pair guy driving offense, but every playoff series the last few years some team's forecheck turns him into a panic merchant and we all act surprised. Meanwhile Tavares' line eats 20 minutes a night and the blue line still gets peppered every second game. That math doesn't win you a Cup, it wins you a second-round exit and a fun autopsy thread.
And yeah, I'd move a forward before Tanev's cheque even clears the bank. We've got forwards coming out of our ears and exactly zero legit top-pair D. Everyone in here will scream about depth, wait for the fanboys to pile in with the "but the cap" takes, and in reality? Every contender around us is loading the blue line while we collect bottom-six wingers like trading cards. 😏
"Every playoff series" is doing a lot of work in that post, which series are you actually talking about? Because Rielly's minutes and matchups have been different each spring, and blaming one guy for getting buried against Boston's forecheck while our forwards float back is lazy. He's not a Bergeron-era Chara, fine, but "panic merchant" is a vibe, not an argument. Show me the shift-level stuff and I'll concede the point, on condition that you also admit the forwards abandoning the zone is half the problem.
And on trading a forward for a top-pair guy: who exactly, and who's paying? Teams don't hand out legit first-pair defencemen in February because we feel nervous. Tanev's cheque matters here too, cap doesn't bend just because the fanbase is twitchy. Might be right that the blue line is short, but gut feeling is an excuse for not doing the homework.
Hype isn't an argument.
Yo I watched Rielly drag that Boston series on one leg, where were the forwards? Blame the guys floating back before you torch our D core 🤬
You don't abandon your own.
ValueDan has a point, and I'd add a caveat from my own notes: Rielly's matchup share has shifted every spring, so comparing series is apples to oranges. That said, the real problem is structural. When Tavares' line logs 20 minutes a night, the blue line starts tired, and you can see it in the shot counts every second game. Small sample though, three or four playoff runs. Fix the usage before the cheque clears on Tanev, then judge Rielly properly.
Numbers > vibes.
Back in my day, every Leafs spring ended the same way, and we blamed whoever was closest. Rielly's fine if the forwards actually come back hard.
Kev_Fan talking about apples to oranges warmed my heart, because I've got a spreadsheet tab literally named "Rielly playoff usage" and it says the same thing. The caveat I'd add is sample size: three or four springs of matchup data isn't enough to crown a trend, depends how you count zone starts too.
My two cents from watching every game with my dad on the couch, Rielly looks fine when the forwards backcheck and lost when they don't. The Tavares minutes thing is the real lever here. If you can move a forward for a true top-pair guy without gutting the middle six, I'd do it yesterday. Until then we're hoping, and hoping isn't a pairing. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Jack_Fan, your spreadsheet tab and mine would get along. I keep a column for playoff zone-start share by defender, and every spring Rielly's starts drift out further while Tavares' line keeps soaking the hard minutes up front. Small sample though, and matchups change series to series, so I'd be careful crowning anyone guilty on that alone.
Here's my honest hang-up. If Tanev's cheque clears and we're still getting outshot every second game, then the forwards coming back hard is a bandage, not a fix. Do we move a forward for a genuine top-pair guy before the deadline? Depends how you count the return value, and that's where I keep going back and forth. Dig a bit deeper into who actually eats the tough minutes and I'm not ready to close the book on this one. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊