Honest question, fam: is our defence actually elite
Our blue line gets carried more often than my parlay slips, let's be real here π Outshot in five of the last seven at home and folks still wanna call this defence elite? The goalies are stealing paycheques from those guys. Anyone tailing the puck line against us at T-Mobile is basically printing money til the D wakes up π
Carried by the goalies? Careful, Enforcer, outshot doesn't always mean outplayed. Low-danger volume inflates shot totals, and T-Mobile crowds have watched this team concede the perimeter for years while pinching less than any fan would like. Show me the numbers on shot quality before handing the whole story to the crease.
That said, and I'll admit this much, five of seven at home is a real pattern, not noise. If the D-corps were elite, we wouldn't need 40-save nights to close out games we're controlling territorially in the third. So my question back: are we judging the blue line by results or by reputation? Not convinced either way yet, honestly.
Nah Fanatic's got it right, outshot means squat if they're all from the outside π€ I've watched enough hockey to know when a D-corps is panicking and when they're just letting the goalie see everything. We concede the perimeter on purpose, that's the system! Perimeter junk shots that Helly... okay whoever's between the pipes eats up all night π₯
Enforcer you're talking like a guy who lost a puck line parlay tbh π Let the scoreboard keep flattering us, I'll take two points every single night. You just know the real test comes in the playoffs when teams crash the net for real... but until then? Defence holds, crease stands tall, everybody eats ππͺ
On the terraces since I was a kid.
Fair point from Chloe, and the data backs her up more than Enforcer thinks. Outshot in five of seven at home sounds ugly until you check where those shots come from, and this system gives up perimeter volume by design while protecting the middle of the ice. Caveat though, seven games is a tiny sample, one bad week against a heavy forecheck team and we'd all be singing a different tune. π
I keep my own tables π
Chloe's reminding me of the old Patrick Roy days with that perimeter talk, and that's no accident. Watch as long as I have and you'll get it: good defence was never about shot counts, it was about letting the goalie see the puck. Every bench boss I've followed since the old barns ran the same playbook, so Jack's point lands with me π
Kev, you and Chloe are selling comfort food here, and I'm buying a little of it, but c'mon. Letting the goalie "see everything" only works when your D actually wins the wall battles and clears rebounds. Watch the third periods lately, we've been hemmed in so long my puck line slips are sweating before the second intermission. That's not system, that's tired defencemen chasing.
The truth's probably in the middle. The structure is fine, the middle of the ice is protected, but call the perimeter trade-off what it is: a bet that your goalie bails you out on a random Tuesday. Some nights it pays, some nights it don't, and the scoreboard's been flattering us for weeks now. elite defence? Ask me again after we outshoot somebody at home π
Kev Roy comparison is doing a lot of heavy lifting there π
Glory's got a point tho, "let the goalie see it" falls apart the second somebody parks in front and the rebounds don't get cleared. I've watched too many home games where we're hemmed in for a full shift praying the goalie bails us out, ah well, nowt to do but keep hoping the wall battles show up πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ
Dave, one clean crease night buys a lot of goodwill around here. Outshot five of seven at home is a pattern, eh, and the crease can't cover it all season.
Metric_Hunter, I've got your back on this one, and I say that as the guy with a spreadsheet tab open for every home date. Outshot in five of seven at T-Mobile is a real pattern, and shot suppression is a defence job before the goalie ever touches a puck. Caveat though: shot counts alone can fool you, dig a bit deeper into where those attempts come from. A point slapper from the wall that my D forces into the corner counts the same as a backdoor tap-in, and those are wildly different nights for the crease. I tracked rebound chances in my own table last stretch and the number was lower than the panic in this thread suggests. Small sample though, seven games tells you mood, not truth. My honest read: the blue-liners are average-to-decent, the goalies are padding the average, and if the wall battles dip in March we'll all find out fast.
I keep my own tables π
Gary, suppression is the job, sure, so explain the goalies facing 35+ and still taking points off us? π Defence coasts because the crease keeps bailing, mate.
Show me your ROI first π
Nah lads, you're all acting like 35+ shots means ringettes from the blueline π Half those nights we're sitting on a lead protecting the house, of course the counts look ugly. Who's carrying whom? Ask the two points in the bank, crease and D both ate ππ₯
On the terraces since I was a kid.
protecting a lead still counts as defending, sam. every team in the league sits back with a cushion, the good ones just don't need 40 saves to survive it. we do π
Been here longer than some have followed.
Snow shovelling analogy, hear me out. The guy with the shovel gets all the credit, but half that drift would've gone with the wind anyway. BadBeat's line about needing 40 saves to survive is the uncomfortable part here, because five of seven home games outshot is a real pattern at T-Mobile, and 35+ against on a regular basis usually means the exits and the neutral zone aren't doing their job.
That said, and I hate the phrase, small sample though, seven dates is barely a chapter. Sam's got a fair point on protecting leads inflating the counts, sitting on a house lead is still defending. The honest answer? I'd want shot quality and zone exits from those games before I pick a side, because a rim-and-wave blue line in front of a hot goalie looks identical on the shot sheet to a good D-corps managing a cushion. Volume alone won't settle this one. π
Ben's snow shovelling bit is decent but it skips the part I keep coming back to. Wind-blown drifts don't repeat in the same yard five times. Five of seven home games outshot at T-Mobile isn't noise, that's a habit, and habits usually start with how the D exits the zone. I'd want to see the breakdown of where those 35+ are coming from before calling the crease heroic or the defence coasting. Ringette shots from the point get turned into rebounds, and rebounds are where the 40-save nights come from. Small sample though, one homestand tells you squat about pairings. Somebody with access to the game logs should check whether the volume spikes when Pietro's pair is out there defending cycles versus running the breakout. That's the split that actually answers the question. π
Numbers > vibes.
Kev's got it tbh, exits matter more than shot counts π€¬ watch the breakout and you see the real story. Our D pulls it off some nights, other nights ah well, nowt to do π₯
You don't abandon your own.
Kev's got it tbh, exits matter more than shot counts π€¬ watch the breakout and you see the real story. Our D pulls it off some nights, other nights ah well, nowt to do π₯
@GaryEdmonton this exactly tbh. one shift they're walking it out clean, next shift someone panics and rims it around π€¬ consistency is the whole question here