Honest question, fam: is Mo Seider already our best defenceman since
Hot take incoming and I'll die on this hill: Seider's been carrying our blue line since day one and I'd hand him the C tomorrow, nostalgia be damned π Half the fanboys in here still clinging to 2008 memories need a reality cheque, laughable really. Guy eats 25 minutes a night against other teams' top lines at 23 and some of you want him to "wait his turn" π€‘π
It's a lottery, not sport.
Carrying the blue line since day one? Show me the numbers behind that, because heavy minutes on a bad team prove workload, not dominance. Seider's 2021-22 Calder season was legit, no argument, but Lidstrom won four Cups and seven Norrises. Give'r a few more years before we hand out letters.
Who did the heavy lifting on this blue line before Mo showed up? Nobody, that's who π€ Kid eats 24 minutes a night against top lines at 21, gimme a break. Cups talk is unfair, Lidstrom had a stacked roster!
You don't abandon your own.
Fanatic_Life actually has a point buried in there, even if it stings. Eating 24 minutes a night at 21 proves Yzerman's staff trusts him with top-pair deployment against other teams' best lines, and workload like that on a rebuilding roster is rare. But it's a workload stat, not a dominance one. Lidstrom's seven Norrises came with the wins attached, so give Mo two or three more seasons of this sample before the C talk, however tempting it is.
I keep my own tables π
Kev's point about apprenticeship is the one I keep. Mo's workload says trust, not greatness yet. Small sample though, ask me in three years π
I keep my own tables π
Fanatic_Life actually has a point buried in there, even if it stings. Eating 24 minutes a night at 21 proves Yzerman's staff trusts him with top-pair deployment against other teams' best lines, and workload like that on β¦
Fair take @Gary_Legend, but three years feels long. I've cashed enough futures to know talent shows in year two, not year four. Trust from the staff already tells me something π₯
Value over a big price πΈ
Twenty-four minutes is fine for a good guy, but greatness requires more than just ice time, mate. Stop betting on history before the final whistle blows.
@YUL99 mate you write like a scout who's never skated a pickup game π€£ the kid's what, 21, dragging the puck end to end like it owes him money. Nobody's calling him Lidstrom yet, we just enjoy the show. Meanwhile in Calgary we're still arguing about our top pair so my standards are low π
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ