Honest debate, family: McDavid needs a new linemate more than the
0-for-4 with the man advantage again and half this thread still wants to blame the blue line? π€‘ McDavid's been dragging the top unit like a scaffolder hauling steel on his own, and nobody wants to give him an actual finisher. So who's first out the door then, and remind me of your ROI on defending that powerplay? π
Show me your ROI first π
Dragging steel, eh? The man had four chances with the man advantage and the whole unit stood around waiting for him to do something. A finisher doesn't fix a powerplay that can't win a faceoff or get zone entries clean. Fix the structure first, then we talk about who rides shotgun.
Where's the proof?
Harry, the structure's been the same all season, how's that working out? π€ Give the man a finisher already. I watched him dangle three guys in Vancouver last spring and Nuge whiffed the rebound, still stings.
On the terraces since I was a kid.
Harry's got half a point and I'll give him that much, but the 0-for-4 sticks with me. Four chances is a small sample, one bad night, fine. My problem is the pattern behind it. When your second line is outproducing the top unit and the powerplay keeps stalling at the blue line, you've got two possible fixes and only one of them fits the cap sheet. A structural tweak costs nothing but practice time. A finisher next to McDavid changes how every opponent sets up against us.
There's a nuance here though, don't hand-wave the zone entries away, because even a elite winger can't score if the puck never gets set. My order of operations: fix the entries with coaching, then move a piece for a legitimate top-six finisher before the deadline. Defence can wait one more window, the leak is upstairs. π
I keep my own tables π
Been saying this since the Coffey days, you win with finishers, not systems. Get Connor a real triggerman and watch that powerplay wake up π
Been here longer than some have followed.
Standing around waiting for him?? That's every powerplay since the playoff miss, not just Saturday π€ Fix the personnel first, ah well, nowt to do π₯
One love, one side β€οΈ
young lot never watched a cup run without one touch of luck in it π we had finishers and the powerplay still went cold some springs, ask anybody who sat through 2006 with me. give McDavid a triggerman and he'll feed him fine, but you don't win much when half the roster can't skate the puck out. trade for both, keep the defence intact.
0-for-4 against a PK that's been leaking all month sounds good but I'm not convinced the forwards are the leak. Defence can't break out either.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
KevUltra's got half the point, honestly. You can hand McDavid the prettiest triggerman in the league and it changes nothing if the breakout is still a fire drill, and that's been my complaint since the playoff miss too. Watch the exit stats the way I chart them and the pattern repeats: first pass into the wall, 200 feet of Connor doing rescue work.
But context matters, and the 0-for-4 stung because the second line was generating more with less. My old man sat through 2006 with me and he keeps saying a cold powerplay in April kills you faster than a soft third pair. I chart both columns every round, and the top unit's shot quality has been drifting for weeks. So my answer is a finisher first, a defenceman second, and if the cap only allows one, I'd still rather watch Connor pass to someone who can actually bury it. π
Do the math before you argue.
Watched the breakout live Saturday, it's a fire drill for sure, but you put a real finisher beside 97 and half those 0-for-4s become goals. Forwards first π
Reminds me of tuning an engine with two leaks, you fix one and the other just gets louder. Small sample though, four powerplays proves nothing either way. π
@Ben_Ultra the two leaks thing is fair but I'd argue one of those leaks pays your bills. I bet the oilers moneyline plenty this year and the nights they buried their chances, the ugly breakout mattered way less. Four PP looks proves nothing, agreed, small samples have burned me on props too many times π
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Four PP looks is nothing, I've lost more money on bigger samples π But I'd take a finisher over a breakout fix first, goals pay the bills.
Bankroll discipline wins.
Where's the evidence that a finisher fixes any of this? McDavid creates chances for whoever's out there, the question is whether the finishing problem is personnel or structure. Four powerplays is nothing, Ben's right about the sample, but everyone in here is treating "get him a sniper" as settled science.
I'd want to see the shot quality data first. If the 0-for-4s were low-danger looks from the perimeter, no linemate bails that out. Receipts please before we rebuild the top six over one Saturday game.
Sample first, conclusions after.