Hertl at second-line centre is a luxury we can't afford anymore
Hertl at second-line centre being untouchable is the funniest take I've read here all month π The bloke's faceoff numbers at T-Mobile Arena have slid since last season and half of you still talk about him like he's 2019 Hertl. Second-line minutes against other teams' checking lines, winning what, half his draws? That's a luxury, mate, and we're paying for it every time we get pinned in our own end after a lost draw.
Move him to third and suddenly that line gets real centre depth instead of hoping somebody chips in. Watch, the same people defending the current setup will be first to blame coaching when it stalls in round one. I'd love to hear the actual argument from the Hertl-at-2C crowd, but I already know it's vibes and a highlight reel from three years ago π€‘ It's a lottery, not sport, if you think that holds up.
It's a lottery, not sport.
Slide since when, exactly? Home faceoff splits bounce around all season, show me a real sample before we demote the guy off one stat.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Nah emma's got a point tbh π€ watched him lose draw after draw at T-Mobile last stretch and my heart sank every time... third line C is where he wins us games, you just know it πͺ
On the terraces since I was a kid.
Bleacher's got the right instinct here. Home faceoff splits are the classic small-sample trap. One cold stretch at T-Mobile and suddenly half the thread wants to move him down a line. I track this stuff round by round, and draws bounce around all season even for elite centres; a few bad weeks tells you almost nothing until you're looking at 30-plus games.
The nuance people keep missing is that a faceoff slide, if it's real, shows up in more than one number - zone starts, shorthanded draws, the coach trusting him late. Until we see that, I'm keeping Hertl at second-line centre and judging him on the full body of work, not last month's tape. Emma's provocative, sure, but the sample doesn't back the demotion yet. Check me again in February π
I keep my own tables π
seen this movie before, folks, back in my day we panicked over every cold month too. give the man a proper stretch before shuffling lines π
Been here longer than some have followed.
Chloe, what exactly did your heart sink over. The draws or the storyline you'd already written for him?
Because "watched him lose draw after draw" is feeling, and feeling is where line shuffles go to die. Home splits wobble all year; a bad month at T-Mobile tells me less than his matchup usage does. Second-line C gets harder opponents every night, of course the percentages dip. Drop him to third line and who exactly wins those tough draws against the top units. The third-line kid? Show me the numbers on that plan before we demote a guy off one cold stretch. Not convinced.
Fanatic_Life nailed it, though I'd add one caveat: usage matters, but if those home draws stay cold after another ten games even I start eyeing the third line π
Context beats a bare stat.
Sure thing, mate, another ten games and suddenly Zoe's an eye doctor too π Funny how everyone here watched him take those draws at T-Mobile and saw a crisis, meanwhile the bloke's still dragging defencemen into the wall on the cycle. You want him on the third line twiddling his thumbs? Might as well bury a C$100 puck line ticket on the Battle of Alberta while you're at it, same odds of it paying off π€‘πΈ
Nah YUL, cycle work don't fix cold draws π€ I watched him lose draw after draw at T-Mobile with my own eyes, and we keep paying second-line centre money for a guy getting bodied on the dot. Ten more games sounds fair tbh, but if those home splits keep sliding ah well, nowt to do but move him down π₯
One love, one side β€οΈ
Kev's got it right, a cold month on the dot never made a bad centre. Cycle work counts too, receipts or not I'll take the ten games before demoting him.
Where's the proof?
Kev, ten games sounds like fair arbitration, I'll give you that, though I'd add a caveat: track his home splits separately, because a road draw can hide a home slide the same way a hot week hides a slump. I keep my own spreadsheet every round, and the pattern I've seen with centres past thirty is that the dot recovers fast but the matchup minutes don't. Small sample though, so yeah, count the ten games before we touch the lines. π
I keep my own tables π
Forty years of watching draws and Kev still thinks vibes beat a home splits slide π Ten games max, then Hertl gets demoted to third-line duty.
Ten games for a guy sliding at our own barn while Eichel's line carries everything? π€ I like Tommy through thick and thin but Emma's got a point on the home splits, nah? Cycle work don't win you the draws that matter late... give him the run then drop him to third if the dot stays ugly, ah well, nowt to do π₯
On the terraces since I was a kid.
Every quarter I catch myself staring at one weird week on a dashboard before remembering to split it by segment. Same instinct applies here. If the T-Mobile draws keep sliding through Kev's ten-game window while the road numbers hold steady, third line starts making sense; if they level off, Harry's patience ages well. Small sample either way, so I'll keep my verdict in my pocket until the home split separates the noise from the slide.
I price the draws into nothing honestly, but ten games with home splits tracked separately is how I'd want any bet graded. If the barn numbers keep sliding, third line it is π₯
Value over a big price πΈ
Nah, 10 games ain't enough to call a guy out. It's getting ridiculous with these splits stuff, tbh. π€π₯
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Nah, 10 games ain't enough to call a guy out. It's getting ridiculous with these splits stuff, tbh. π€π₯
@Toronto_North you'd be right if the splits were some weird quirk nobody can explain, but the point of splitting by venue is exactly that nobody's calling a guy out on vibes. Ten games is thin for a season verdict, sure. Ten games where the home faceoff numbers slide while the road ones hold steady is a pattern worth checking before it costs you a late draw in your own building.
Nobody's shipping him to the Maritimes over it. If the T-Mobile numbers level off, everyone drops it and Hertl stays at 2C. If they keep sliding, the "luxury" argument writes itself. Feels like fans want the small sample to be too small until it isn't, and by then the third-line conversation's already been had for a month.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.