Blow it up or stay the course
Nineteen losses in twenty-five and half the building's still doing the wave for him every shift, and some of you honestly think that core deserves another three years? 😂 That's Leafs Nation math, that is. Feelings over roster reality, hope over odd-man rushes against every single night.
I put a cheeky C$50 on the puck line against us last month because the defence just doesn't survive a forecheck, and it cashed easier than a Connor Bedard prop. Keep the kids, move the furniture around them, sure. But chanting a guy's name while he watches three backsips go past him? Laughable really. You're not rebuilding around a core, mate, you're rebuilding around a memory. 🤡💸
Show me your ROI first 😏
Leafs Nation math, eh? Last I checked we're in Chicago, and 19 of 25 says the roster is bad, which everyone here already agrees on. My question is who exactly you'd keep if you blow it up tonight. Names, contract terms, expected return. Otherwise it's just vibes with extra steps.
Half the barn still chants his name because he's earned it, that's heart not delusion 🙌 Swap him for what exactly, a draft pick and prayers? Ah well, nowt to do but keep the faith 🔥💪
You don't abandon your own.
Fair question from Fanatic_Life, so here's my honest answer on names: there's a nuance here, because nobody's trading the young guys, you move the veterans with term and take the return. The 19 losses in 25 aren't random noise either, that sample screams structural problems when the odd-man rushes against keep coming shift after shift. Keep the core pieces the crowd loves if they fit the timeline, but pretending this group as built deserves three more years is where I get off the bus 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
been through a few of these teardowns myself, back in my day we watched whole cores get wheeled out the side door and the barn still sold out. jack's got it right, nobody touches the kids, you ship the veterans with term and take what the market gives. i sat through rebuilds worse than this one, they feel endless right up until the picks start landing, so no, i don't think we're delaying anything by keeping the young core intact 😄
Been here longer than some have followed.
Been keeping my own sheet on this all month and here's where I land: the odd-man rushes against aren't a coaching quirk, they've shown up in 4 of 5 losses I charted, and that's a personnel problem wearing a system costume. Jack and BadBeat are right on the shape of it, kids stay, veterans with term go, and the return depends how you count it, picks versus prospects versus cap dumps folded in.
Where I'd push back on everyone a bit, Millie included: chanting a guy's name through a 19-of-25 skid doesn't tell us anything about his trade value, it tells us about the crowd. Those are two different questions and half this thread keeps answering the wrong one. I could be wrong, but I think the honest answer is we don't know yet what the market pays us until someone actually calls, so my verdict stays open. Ask me again after the deadline chatter gets real. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Zamboni's chart matches what my eyes told me watching the losses, those odd-man rushes kept killing me on the puck line. If it's personnel, that's your case for moving veterans with term, buyers pay a premium for a responsible defenceman at the deadline. Tear it down properly and the return might actually land 🍺
Up one week, down the next. Classic.