Trade a top-six winger for a true top-pair defenceman
I'd pull that trigger tomorrow honestly. Sid's clock is ticking and watching rushes fly through the neutral zone every home game is worse than losing a winger's 25 goals, you can find scoring by committee. Half this fan club would rather keep a pretty forward and lose in round one, laughable really 😏
Scoring by committee, on whose roster exactly? Name the true top-pair D actually available for a 25-goal winger and I'll listen. So far, nobody's shown me one.
I'd rather watch a 2-1 nail-biter with actual defence than another 6-5 track meet where Sid's stuck watching rushes fly past him 😤 we've lived through that leaky neutral zone long enough. And tbh committees can score, heart says it all 🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Fanatic_Life's got a point though, there's a nuance here. Who exactly is on the market? Without a true number one D available, moving a 25-goal winger solves nothing.
I keep my own tables 📊
back in the day we traded for Larry Murphy at the deadline and he looked cooked until he wasn't, two cups after that 😄 point being, a real number one D shows up when you least expect it, so I wouldn't sell a 25-goal winger for a lukewarm second-pairing guy dressed up as one. patience, boys.
Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
back in the day we traded for Larry Murphy at the deadline and he looked cooked until he wasn't, two cups after that 😄 point being, a real number one D shows up when you least expect it, so I wouldn't sell a 25-goal wing…
@ValueHunter murphy thing is fair tbh, that deal looked like a disaster for a good stretch, my old man wouldnt shut up about it 😂 but heres my worry, waiting for deadline magic assumes someone panics and puts a real 1D on the block. thats a big bet on luck.
id rather keep the winger AND shop picks/prospects at the deadline, only sell him if an actual number one shows up, not some "top-pair energy" guy like Fanatic said 🤣 pitchforks come out fast in this city if we swap 25 goals for a plug on the blue line. ah well, nowt to do but wait and see 🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
ValueHunter's Murphy point is the one that keeps me honest here. I keep a spreadsheet on this sort of thing and the pattern holds: real number ones rarely get listed in October, they surface near the deadline when a contender panics. Small sample though, two cups ago is two cups ago. So my honest answer is hold the winger for now and check the board again in February, unless someone upgrades the return.
Numbers > vibes.
Murphy trade almost didn't happen, remember folks screaming about it. Patience is right, you don't move a 25-goal winger in October out of itchiness 😄
Seen it all, trust me.
Fanatic_Life's got a point though, there's a nuance here. Who exactly is on the market? Without a true number one D available, moving a 25-goal winger solves nothing.
@Jack_Fan right, like who's even out there, a guy with a beard and a "top-pair energy" sticker on him? 🤣 I'll wait till the deadline panic sale, patience is free.