Swayman and Ullmark were never the problem
These guys were amazing with the pads, absolutely, but honestly, how long are we gonna pretend that’s the full story? Watching that TD Garden game, 42-18, makes it crystal clear where the real problem is. We've got McAvoy doing everything, and in reality? our defence has just been coasting on him for two whole seasons. 🤡💸😏
One game with a 42-18 shot count and suddenly the whole blue line is on trial? I'd want more than that before burying Carlo and Lindholm. Show me the numbers over a full stretch of season, because a single stinker at TD Garden where the goalies still stole a point can happen to anyone.
I'll grant you McAvoy carries a silly load, that part might be right, on condition that someone shows me the pairing split data, not just a bad night we all remember. What were the shutdown minutes without him? If the drop-off is real, fair enough, blame the defence. If it's not, maybe the shot suppression collapsed in specific matchups and we're rewriting the story around one ugly Tuesday.
Hype isn't an argument.
One game?? I was at that TD Garden night, 42-18 and they still stole a point, get in! 😤 McAvoy's been carrying this blue line for two seasons, eh, open your eyes 🏒
On the terraces since I was a kid.
ValueDan, fair point about sample size, and you know I'm the first guy to ask for a bigger n before drawing conclusions 📊 But the 42-18 night isn't the whole case. It's just the loudest exhibit. The pattern holds across two seasons of my tracking: shot suppression collapses whenever McAvoy sits or draws the top matchup, and both goalies have consistently posted numbers above expected save percentage while facing second-chance traffic all night. One game can be an outlier, sure, but when the underlying shot counts keep telling the same story, that's a blue line problem wearing a goalie controversy costume.
I'd still love a proper split of chances against with and without Carlo on the ice before I bury anyone, caveats about my sample apply. But two years of the same shape to the data? That stops being noise. Swayman and Ullmark have been stealing points we had no business collecting.
I keep my own tables 📊
Back in the old Garden days we never needed one stud to bail out the blue line every night. McAvoy's been doing that dance for two seasons now, enough said. 😉
Seen it all, lads.
I watched that night from section 108, and honestly half those 42 shots were rebounds off soft exits. McAvoy eating 25-plus minutes two seasons running, that's the tell.
Where's the proof?
HarryBeliever, that bit about soft exits leading to rebounds is the part nobody wants to sit with. I keep a little spreadsheet every round, and the pattern holds whether it's Swayman or Ullmark in the net: the danger chances come off broken clears, not clean zone entries. One night at section-whatever is a story, two seasons of McAvoy eating 25-plus minutes is a trend 📊
Small sample though, one game proves nothing on its own, I grant Jack that much. But when your goalie steals a point getting peppered 42-18, the confession is written on the blue line. My caveat, and I'll keep saying it: fix the exits and McAvoy's minutes drop to something human, then the goalie debate dissolves on its own. Until then we're asking him to do the whole dance every night, and I remember my old man saying the same about Bourque's era. Some things don't change.
Ben_Ultra your spreadsheet thing actually tracks, the broken clears get us burned every time 😅 And if McAvoy keeps eating 25-plus a night somebody should tip his agent, cause that contract is worth every loonie. Watch the fanboys blame the goalies again next round though, laughable really.
It's a lottery, not sport.
Nah, Amy, fanboys blaming the goalies? We're the ones saying the goalies saved our season 😂 But real talk, 42-18 at home and we're still debating? McAvoy at 25-plus a night, two straight years, of course the exits get soft when he's gassed. Get somebody who can carry a puck out and watch Sway look like a Vezina guy again 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
Watching that 42-18 night, I think most of the discussion is narrowly focused on who stopped the puck, but the structural issue around the blue line is what keeps surfacing in my own observations. McAvoy is absolutely doing the heavy lifting, yes, but those continuous broken clears leading to danger chances tell a much more consistent story about defensive coverage than any single goalie performance. We're seeing a pattern, not just an anomaly.
Do the math before you argue.
Watching that 42-18 night, I think most of the discussion is narrowly focused on who stopped the puck, but the structural issue around the blue line is what keeps surfacing in my own observations. McAvoy is absolutely do…
How much more analysis are we gonna see on this thing ah well, nowt to do.
It's tough when everybody starts looking at the tiny things instead of just appreciating the grinder work, tbh. McAvoy is pushing himself to the limit and the structure of the game is just kinda whatever, right? Heart says it all and these guys are going to fight through the mess regardless of what the spreadsheets say. 💪🔥
One love, one side ❤️
They really assume structural issues mean something when they just mean they got unlucky on the crease, haven't they? Before you start debating blue line geometry, we’d need the actual exit progression metrics to substantiate any claim beyond "soft." Until then, it’s all just noise built around McAvoy’s workload.
Where's the proof?