Second Whistle
Nov 22, 6:14 PM Log in Sign up
Colorado Avalanche

Makar is already the best defenceman in franchise history - yes

club debate Colorado Avalanche Fans Colorado Avalanche 7 posts ·1 view ·Posted: Nov 21, 2026, 2:55 PM ·Updated: Nov 21, 2026, 7:16 PM
PA Paul_Regina Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 31 posts Nov 21, 2026, 2:55 PM
Makar at 26 is already putting up Norris numbers Bourque needed a decade here to even sniff, and Cale's puck-moving alone wins you playoff rounds. Ray gave us his farewell tour and one glorious Cup at 40, beautiful story, but I'd take prime Makar in game 7 every single time. Fight me, Bourque enjoyers 😏
Any stat can be bent.
Reply Quote
Paul_Regina wrote:
Makar at 26 is already putting up Norris numbers Bourque needed a decade here to even sniff, and Cale's puck-moving alone wins you playoff rounds. Ray gave us his farewell tour and one glorious Cup at 40, beautiful story…
FA Fanatic_Life Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 565 posts Nov 21, 2026, 3:18 PM
Norris pace at 26 against what competition, though? Ray ran 20 seasons here. Show me the numbers after a decade, not eight years in.
Reply Quote
ST Steve_Fan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 133 posts Nov 21, 2026, 4:46 PM
Nah Paul's got me riled up but he's right 😤 Ray's farewell season and that Cup at 40 was a fairytale, greatest moment of my hockey life tbh, but fairytales don't pick your all-time lineup. Makar at 26 is already doing things on the blue line nobody in this franchise has ever done, and he's got rings coming if the core stays together 🔥 Fanatic_Life, I hear ya on the longevity question, I really do. Ten more years of this and it's not even a debate. But if Cale tears an ACL tomorrow I'd still say best defenceman we've ever had here, peak for peak. Backing him all day 💪 ah well, nowt to do but enjoy the ride while we got it.
Colorado Avalanche ice hockey game
On the terraces since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
GA Gary_Legend Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 396 posts Nov 21, 2026, 5:11 PM
Fanatic_Life, I get the caution, but you're grading two different assignments there. Ray's 20 seasons here were brilliant, yet only one of them produced a Cup, and that was at 40 with Sakic and Foote already carrying the room. Makar at 26 is winning Norrises outright and driving play the way no Avs defenceman ever has. Peak value beats tenure in my book, and I keep a whole spreadsheet that says the same thing 📊 Small sample though, sure, eight years against twenty. So flip it: if Makar tears an ACL tomorrow, would you still rank him over Ray? Probably not. But longevity arguments are cheap, every era has a guy who hung around. Give me the peak that wins you a game 7. That's prime Makar, and honestly it isn't close.
I keep my own tables 📊
Reply Quote
DA DaveArmy Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 406 posts Nov 21, 2026, 6:20 PM
funny thing is I watched Bourque play his whole run here, had seats through those years, and I still can't say I'd take 1996 Ray over today's Makar in a game 7. back in the day the old barns used to shake every time Ray fired one from the point, and that Cup at 40... you don't forget a moment like that, it's part of why we're all still here 🙄 but fairytales and defenceman rankings are two different conversations. where I land after all these years is this: longevity buys you love, prime buys you titles. Ray gave us twenty good seasons and one night we'll never forget. Cale at 26 is already the whole powerplay and half the transition game on his own. ask me again when Makar's got grey hairs and a decade of mileage, maybe the answer changes. but if you're picking a lineup to win right now, I've seen it all before and the kid's the pick 😄
Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
Reply Quote
BA BadBeatPTSD Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 393 posts Nov 21, 2026, 6:30 PM
dave, I sat through those Ray years too and loved every one, but game 7 in 2025 I'm handing the puck to Makar every shift and never looking back 😉 twenty seasons of loyalty earns you the statue outside, it doesn't earn him the lineup spot over a guy winning Norrises at 26. watch as long as I have and you'll get it, the fairytale and the best are two different conversations.
Seen it all, lads.
Reply Quote
JA Jack_Fan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 1002 posts Nov 21, 2026, 7:16 PM
I keep a table on this every season, and even my own spreadsheet can't settle it 📊 Peak value says Makar, no argument from me. But peak value over what sample? Ray gave us twenty seasons here, Makar's given us what, seven? Ask me again in 2036 when Cale's got 1,400 games in burgundy and blue, and I suspect the vote gets a lot less spicy. Both things can be true at once. statue outside Ball Arena for Ray, first pairing in any hypothetical game 7 for Makar. Depends how you count it, and honestly the counting isn't finished yet.
Colorado Avalanche ice hockey action
I keep my own tables 📊
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.