Let's settle it, folks: was the 2023 Cup run peak hockey or did we
Peak hockey, no debate. That run wasn't luck, we rolled Florida in five and outscored half the league doing it. Eichel, Stone playing on one leg with a broken back basically, Hill standing on his head. You don't get that by accident.
And to anyone calling the Tkachuk save luck, watch it again. Hill reads the 2-on-1, gets across and seals the post with the paddle. That's positioning, mate. Some of you lot would call a shutout a fluke too 😏 I had the puck line that series and even I'll admit the wins were earned. Lightning in a bottle? Laughable really, we'd been knocking for years. 🤡💸
It's a lottery, not sport.
Peak hockey, no debate. That run wasn't luck, we rolled Florida in five and outscored half the league doing it. Eichel, Stone playing on one leg with a broken back basically, Hill standing on his head. You don't get that…
Rolled Florida, sure, but one save doesn't make a legend. Where's Hill's body of work before that run? Show me the numbers and I'll reconsider.
Fanatic_Life, since when does a guy need a decade of work to be called legendary? That save WAS the body of work, right there in one moment. Tkachuk alone in tight, looks like a tap in, and Hill somehow stretches across and takes the whole top corner away 😱 I've watched it maybe fifty times and I still don't believe my eyes.
And the bloke didn't just have one moment, he backed it up the rest of the series against Florida. We win that Cup with him standing on his head, plain and simple. Body of work? Five wins in the final, including that Game 5 clincher at home. Our lot never make it easy, and he made it look easy anyway 🔥💪 If that's luck, hand me a loonie's worth of that luck every June, ah well, nowt to do but keep rewatching it.
In the stands since I was a kid.
Fanatic_Life, fair question, and I keep a sheet every round so I get why you'd ask for a body of work. My honest answer depends how you count it. A single save isn't a career, no argument there, but context matters. That stop came in Game 4 against Florida with Tkachuk alone in tight and the whole series swinging on it, and Hill took away the top corner with a stretch that most goalies simply don't make. Legend status gets earned in moments like that, whether the save percentage before it was pretty or not.
My nuance would be this: compare the run itself with the resume. The resume was thin, sure. The run? Eichel driving play, Stone basically playing on one leg, and Hill holding up his end against a Panthers team that had battered everybody to get there. Lightning in a bottle is when everything clicks and nobody gets hurt. Peak hockey is when the guys on the ice rise to the exact second the season dies without them. We watched both at once, which is why the argument never settles. 📊
Do the math before you argue.
Reminds me of the old Smythe Division days, watching goalies nobody had heard of steal a round then vanish. Back in my day we used to say a goalie needs one great save and one lucky save in every series, and the trick is nobody remembers which was which. That Hill stop on Tkachuk, I don't care which column it goes in, the timing is what makes it legend. Game 4, tight game, Florida pressing, and he takes the top corner away from a guy who's been burying chances all spring. Lucky? Maybe the geometry was kind. But luck only counts when you're positioned well enough to receive it, and that comes from work.
Body of work argument, I get it, Fanatic_Life made fair points and RideOrDieZone sheetkeeping habit deserves a nod 😄. But here's my two cents from decades of watching: dynasties write resumes, cup runs write moments. Hill gave us the moment and then backed it up the rest of the series. You don't get to rewrite history just because the guy didn't have a decade of tape before it.
Kev just summed up my whole spreadsheet in one line, honestly. I've got Hill's Game 4 sequence logged next to the scoring chances against and the sample size tells you it was tight, but it can't tell you whether that stretch defied physics or fortune. Ask me again in three or four seasons, once we know whether 2023 was a foundation or a fluke 📊
I keep my own tables 📊