Honestly, trading away our first-round picks every year is killing
Mortgaging the farm for Stone's cap tricks worked once, congrats on the 2023 banner, hope you lot enjoy rewatching it every June for the next decade π€‘ I'd rather whiff on a playoffs one spring and actually draft a kid who turns into something, since Dorofeyev's basically our entire development rΓ©sumΓ© this decade. Keep mortgaging though, sure thing mate πΈ
Show me your ROI first π
Rewatching a banner every June sounds like a problem I'd happily take, honestly. You're framing one Cup and a parade as luck, but Stone's cap situation was a deliberate roster plan that produced exactly what it was built to produce. That's evidence, not a clown emoji.
As for Dorofeyev being "our entire development", he's the most recent example, sure, but one data point doesn't prove a pipeline is dead, it proves nobody's counted the whole pipeline yet. And "I'd rather miss the playoffs once" is easy to type in October. Ask any fanbase sitting out a spring how noble the draft board feels. I'll believe the rebuild-and-develop route works when I see it work here, not in theory. Until then I'll take the banner and the window.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
You just know the banner crew is right here. Kev said it, that Stone cap plan was deliberate and it delivered a Cup, you don't throw that back π Show me another franchise that went from expansion joke to hanging a banner in six years, I'll wait.
And nah, the "no prospects" panic is overblown tbh. Dorofeyev broke through didn't he? Kid's producing right now. If we whiff on playoffs one spring like StandsGuy wants, you know what happens? Empty arena, tank talk, and no guarantee the drafted kid turns into anything anyway π± Draft lottery is a casino, ask Toronto how many top picks got them past round one. I'll take Stone, Eichel, and the window every single year π₯πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ
TomYVR, I actually half agree with you, but there's a nuance here: the Stone cap plan delivered 2023, fine, but since Dorofeyev the pipeline has given us almost nobody who stuck in the lineup, and one banner doesn't pay interest forever. Depends how you count it, sure, but if the sample is "every pick since roughly 2020 is gone," I'd take one lean spring to restock.
I keep my own tables π
Jack_Fan has it about right. back in my day I watched teams trade every first-rounder chasing one spring, and the bill always came due a few years later. the 2023 banner is real and nobody can take it from us, but Dorofeyev being basically the only kid who stuck says plenty. a lean year or two in exchange for a pipeline again wouldn't be the end of the world π
Been here longer than some have followed.
Jack, what does "almost nobody" even mean here, because Dorofeyev sticking is one data point, and one Cup window that actually cashed is another. Show me the numbers on how many of those traded firsts would have made our lineup anyway. Not convinced a missed spring fixes anything, ask Leafs Nation how draft picks feel in round one every April.
Fanatic_Life, fair challenge, and small sample though it is, my worry is the bill always shows up two years late. Kept my own picks table since the expansion draft, and it's grim.
Context beats a bare stat.
Poyle sure showed up ready, huh Zoe π Your spreadsheet hobby aside, I'll side with the banner crowd here, mostly because whiffing on draft picks is a coin flip I've watched lose at the Battle of Alberta up north plenty of times. Give me Dorofeyev plus a parade ring and I'll sleep fine.</arg_value>
Enforcer_YYZ sleeping fine on one kid and a ring from 2023, that's cute π
but the window's closing and then what? Dorofeyev's not gonna carry a lineup alone. Zoe's spreadsheet being grim is the whole point tbh π₯
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Funny how a coin flip sounds great until you flip it eleven times in a row, eh. Enforcer, I get the comfort of the banner, but the question ParlayPain is asking is the one that keeps me up: the window closes, and then what do you restock with? Dorofeyev sticking is one data point, and Fanatic_Life is right to call that out, small sample though it is. My picks table since expansion doesn't prove every traded first would have made the lineup, but it shows the pipeline kept getting emptied right when the bill came due, same way Leaf fans kept telling themselves the next deal would fix it. Two more years of this and we're the next cautionary tale instead of the 2023 highlight reel. I'm not saying torch the roster tomorrow, I'm saying the answer isn't settled and Zoe's spreadsheet deserves better than a Poyle joke.
I keep my own tables π
Poyle sure showed up ready, huh Zoe π Your spreadsheet hobby aside, I'll side with the banner crowd here, mostly because whiffing on draft picks is a coin flip I've watched lose at the Battle of Alberta up north plenty oβ¦
@Gary_Legend this is kinda where I get lost too, still learning this stuff π
so forgive me if it's daft. But like, if you never restock during the window, doesn't the window just close faster? Feels like you'd want at least some picks maturing in the background π€· thanks for explaining the coin flip thing btw, that image kinda stuck with me
@Gary_Legend this is kinda where I get lost too, still learning this stuff π
so forgive me if it's daft. But like, if you never restock during the window, doesn't the window just close faster? Feels like you'd want at leβ¦
@GrampsFaithful1979 Not daft at all, that's the whole argument. A pick you keep today is a roster spot in five years; a rental is a party that ends when the window does.
Hype isn't an argument.
Enforcer_YYZ sleeping fine on one kid and a ring from 2023, that's cute π
but the window's closing and then what? Dorofeyev's not gonna carry a lineup alone. Zoe's spreadsheet being grim is the whole point tbh π₯
@ParlayPainFC nah you're right, my plan for the post-window years is literally crying into a Double Double and refreshing TradeCentre for scraps π€£ I keep a spreadsheet too btw, mine tracks how many times I said "one more year of this roster" out loud. Spoiler: grim as Zoe's. Great, carry on π
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ