Honest debate, Wings family
Mo already is our best defenceman and honestly it's not even a debate for anyone who's watched more than a period this year. 24+ a night against second pairs and PP1, and he's still the one driving play out of our zone. Meanwhile half this thread's ready to canonise Chiarot because he "eats hard minutes" as if surviving your own mistakes counts as skill 😂
Chiarot's fine, he's a depth guy paid like a top-pairer having a nice funeral march up the depth chart. Wait for the fanboys to pile in telling me shutdown minutes are the same thing as actually being good. Bet your house on Mo being the one other GMs phone about, not the geezer wrestling forwards in front of our net 🤡
It's a lottery, not sport.
Driving play against second pairs while Chiarot eats the McDavids and the Marners every night, and we're calling Mo the best already? Sure, 24+ minutes sounds impressive, but who'd want those shutdown minutes on their corsi? Seider might be our top defenceman soon enough, on condition that he learns to win those minutes first.
Hype isn't an argument.
Watched Chiarot get walked by McDavid twice last month and I'm supposed to be scared of these takes? 😱 Mo eats 24+ a night, runs the PP, breaks out clean every shift, that's a franchise d-man. Heart says it all, big Mo all day 💪🔥
One love, one side ❤️
Dan's got a point though,难度 of deployment matters. Chiarot drawing the McDavid shift every night skews everyone's numbers. Small sample to call it either way, honestly. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Saw Nick Lidstrom quietly take the hardest minutes for years and nobody called it flashy, so deployment talk makes me smile. Both kids matter here. Mo at 24-plus a night running our breakout is already the best we've got, and Chiarot eating those McDavid shifts is exactly why Mo gets room to drive play. Old school answer? We need both, quit picking sides 😉
Seen it all, lads.
Gary_Legend nailed it for me, deployment difficulty is doing all the heavy lifting in this argument. My caveat: even accounting for who Mo faces, 24-plus a night as a young d-man is a workload you don't hand to just anyone, so I lean his way. Only warning I'd give is sample size, we're partway into a season and I've had my tables look brilliant in November and silly by March 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Anyone here actually watched Chiarot exit the zone with the puck? 😂 I have, in my living room, screaming at the TV. Seider drives the breakout, runs the PP1, eats 24-plus a night, that's the whole argument. Chiarot takes the tough shifts, love him for it, but tough minutes against McDavid while giving the puck away twice a period isn't a skill, mate. Remind me of your ROI on that take? 🤡😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Mo against second pairs at 24+ a night, Chiarot eating McDavid shifts... you're asking different questions tbh 🔥 Both fill a role. Case closed? Nah 😤
One love, one side ❤️
Uncle_Faithful, nobody's saying Chiarot is the better puck mover. Watch as long as I have and you'll get it, the shutdown guy is why Mo gets that freedom 😄
Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
Chiarot’s ability to hold the top guys at bay is a beauty, that sets up the whole night for them.
ZamboniNation has it right, you're really asking two different questions here. Mo's the better player by any way you count it, but I've watched enough shutdown shifts against those top lines to know Chiarot's the one soaking the bruises so Mo can run the puck. Best defenceman? Seider. Most valuable to the structure? That's a fair argument for Ben.
Do the math before you argue.
DaveArmy talking like 40 years of watching guys get outskated makes Chiarot's slow feet a virtue 😂 Mo runs the whole blueline, that's why he gets the hard minutes too, not some reward for Chiarot "soaking bruises". I'd take Seider over half the league's number one D, laughable really that this is even a poll. Wait for the Chiarot fanboys to pile in now 🤡
Enforcer_YYZ, slow feet eh? Watch him box out guys twice his speed and tell me feet are the whole story 😅
Mo's clearly the best player on our blueline, no argument there. But hard minutes aren't just totals, they're WHO you're out there against. Chiarot's eating the top lines' best shifts every single night so Mo can run free with softer matchups. That's a job and he does it, ugly or not 🔥
Both are ours, both matter. Can't we just love the big fella a little? 🙌
funny thing, i sat behind the glass at the old barn back in the day watching guys like cheli eat those same minutes, and nobody called them the best d-man for it. enforcer, you're right that mo gets the hard shifts too, but watch a saturday night game on hockey night in canada and tell me who's matched against the other team's best every third shift. mo's the better player, no question in my mind, but chi's doing the dirty work the way i've seen it done for forty years 😉
Been here longer than some have followed.
funny thing, i sat behind the glass at the old barn back in the day watching guys like cheli eat those same minutes, and nobody called them the best d-man for it. enforcer, you're right that mo gets the hard shifts too, …
@BadBeat_Nightmare ha, fair point about cheli but that's kind of my whole thing... everyone remembers the minutes, nobody remembers Mo doing them at 23 🔥 kid plays big against top lines every saturday and STILL skates the puck out clean, i've watched enough cold nights at LCA and on tv to back him all day. Best player on the blueline? nah that's still Mo for me, trust me.
Funny reading this thread with my little spreadsheet open, because both sides keep proving each other right 📊 Mo's 24+ minutes tell you Yzerman's staff trusts him with everything, and Chiarot eating the top lines tells you they trust him with the scariest thing. Best player? Seider, comfortably. Most valuable role? Maybe still Ben's. Small sample though, give it thirty more games and we'll argue again.
Context beats a bare stat.
A spreadsheet tells you who is trusted with minutes, but it doesn't always tell you if that trust translates to actual impact.
Are we really meant to equate high defensive usage rates with elite performance, or is that just a proxy for who the coach has found least objectionable on the night? If Mo runs the whole line, as claimed, why is Chiarot consistently given the top-tier power minutes too? I'd need to see a conversion rate analysis before I start ranking them by importance.
Hype isn't an argument.
Funny reading this thread with my little spreadsheet open, because both sides keep proving each other right 📊 Mo's 24+ minutes tell you Yzerman's staff trusts him with everything, and Chiarot eating the top lines tells y…
@ZoeTillIDie nah the spreadsheet backs me up tbh, 24+ a night at 23 means they cant take him off the ice 🔥 trust aint a coincidence, coaches dont hand the whole workload to a guy who cant handle it. watched him skate out of his own end all season, you just know when the kid's got it 💪
On the terraces since I was a kid.
@ZoeTillIDie nah the spreadsheet backs me up tbh, 24+ a night at 23 means they cant take him off the ice 🔥 trust aint a coincidence, coaches dont hand the whole workload to a guy who cant handle it. watched him skate out…
@ChloeUltra minutes are one thing, impact is another, and I'd want the impact before I touch anything Seider-adjacent. Same way I won't drop C$ on a big price until I've checked the goalie, I don't trust workload alone as a stat. Would those 24+ have landed you anything Saturday? 🔥
Up one week, down the next. Classic.