Honest debate, Wings family
Look, I know we love the C-man, he’s been carrying us for ages, but are we really pretending he’s untouchable? People talk about the second-line guys being better, but that just shows how much talent we've stacked around him rather than him being definitively "the guy" anymore.
Seriously, let's get this settled once and for all. Does Larkin still hold the absolute center throne or are we already looking at a gradual shift? My money's on things being less stable than the history suggests. Wait for the fanboys to pile in with their "but he wore the C" rubbish while he slips from dominant force to merely *good*. 💸😏😂
It's a lottery, not sport.
"Carrying us for ages" on what, exactly? Give me one season where he dragged a bad roster to something. The C is a logo. Show me the numbers.
Larkin's been our heart through some DARK years 🔥 the C ain't a logo, it's earned. You show me someone else who'd wear it better. Nah, me neither 💪
I keep my own sheets every round, and I'll say the quiet part out loud: Fanatic_Life has a point, even though it hurts. There's a nuance here though. The numbers I'd actually want are Larkin's even strength scoring relative to the second-line centre, and honestly nobody in this thread has posted them yet. Depends how you count it too, because if the kid is facing softer matchup lines every night, his even strength outperformance gets cheaper to produce.
What I'll grant AmyZone is this: talent around him is stacked deeper now, so the carry job looks smaller by design. That's a roster feature. But "the C is a logo" goes too far. You can't chart leadership on a spreadsheet, and nobody from those rebuild years would argue it was earned. My honest read? If the kid keeps outproducing him at evens into the spring, the internal bump up the depth chart does the talking for us, and the title debate sorts itself out without anybody having to say the word "torch".
Do the math before you argue.
Seen this argument before, boys. Back in my day we had the same fight over Yzerman when Fedorov was clearly the better player some nights, and nobody ripped the C off Steve over it. The letter means something the spreadsheets can't print. Larkin earns his keep the old way.
Been here longer than some have followed.
BadBeat's Yzerman-Fedorov bit is fair, but funny how everyone forgets Fedorov was winning those head-to-head shifts and Steve still kept the letter. So the question isn't whether the second-line kid outplays Larkin some nights, it's whether he changes the room. Show me the numbers at even strength first, then we'll talk about the C.
Hype isn't an argument.
ValueDan's room question is the right one, honestly, and I don't have a clean answer for it. My sheet says the even strength gap this season is thin enough that nobody should be losing sleep over it, small sample though when you split by linemates. Fedorov never took the letter off Yzerman either, so maybe both things get to be true at once. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.