Forget the fancy winger, we need a left-shot defenceman who can
Word is management's kicking tires on a stay-at-home lefty before the deadline, nothing solid yet but supposedly a few names in play. Hughes dragging 26 a night while the rest of the blue line loses every board battle down low is getting old fast. Bring in someone who can actually clear the crease at Rogers and let him run the offense properly. Wait for the fanboys to insist Soucy's the answer 😏
Word is management's kicking tires? Show me the numbers on that rumour, because "supposedly a few names" sounds like the usual deadline noise. Not convinced.
Fanatic_Life has a point about the noise, but the logic behind the rumour holds up better than most deadline chatter. Teams hunting a left-shot defensive D usually pay a premium because the supply is thin, every contender wants the same profile, and sellers know it. That means a first plus a roster player or a decent prospect, unless Allvin finds a cap-strapped team dumping a guy for futures. Age matters too: the ideal target is 27-31, still mobile enough to survive Hughes' pace, old enough to have the battle habits we're missing. A 34-year-old on expiring money is the cheaper path but you're renting half a season.
Caveat as always with deadline rumours, the sample of reliable reporting this early is tiny, so treat "a few names in play" as smoke until a real beat guy confirms. Still, if management is serious about cutting Hughes down toward 23-24 minutes a night, this is the one move that actually fixes it.
I keep my own tables 📊
Jack_Fan, the "thin supply, everyone wants the same profile" bit is exactly the kind of logic that makes sellers jack the price up every March 📊 depends how you count it, but pay a premium for a third-pairing guy who can bump a winger off the crease? I'd rather see what Myers and the kids give us before we burn picks on deadline tax.
Do the math before you argue.
Pricey for a third-pairing body, sure - but I watched enough spring series' collapse in our own crease to know a crease-clearer earns his keep. Paid through the nose for a depth defenceman back in my day and grumbled the whole ride home; turned out the fella anchored our second pair for years. Cheap deals win nothing in March, folks 😉
Every game at Rogers I watch Hughes fish pucks out of our net like he's paying rent down there, while the other five D take turns losing the same board battle 😅 KevReds might be onto something, my old man paid through the nose for a crease-bumper once and that guy was still our favourite by Christmas. Grab the wrong lefty though and it's a lottery, not sport 💸
@MillieBlues that Hughes image is painfully accurate 😅 Maybe I'm wrong but wouldn't a slow crease-bumper just make Hughes skate even harder? RobLegend's skating point worries me too.
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
KevReds, fair point, and I'm inclined to agree, with the condition that the guy we bring in can actually skate. I've seen enough "stay-at-home" types who can't keep pace with Hughes' reads and end up dragging the pairing down instead of freeing him up. That's the caveat nobody wants to hear in March when the prices spike.
Personal note: I coached minor hockey out in Kitchener for a few seasons, and the kid who cleared creases best on our team was also the only defenceman who could retrieve pucks behind his own net without panicking. That's the profile, heavy AND mobile. If management pays a premium for a stationary body, we'll be right back here complaining that Hughes is still playing 26 minutes because the new fella can't exit the zone. Receipts please before anyone celebrates the rumour.
Hype isn't an argument.
seen this movie before, folks. Every deadline some insider floats a crease-clearing lefty and by march it's someone else's division rival doing the deal while we stand pat. been holding season tickets since the pylons in the old barn and watched a dozen of these rumours evaporate. rob's right about the skating though. time will tell 😉
Been here longer than some have followed.
Sorry if this is a daft question, still learning the D-side stuff 😅 Does a crease-bumper need to skate well, or just be big? Thanks Barnburner_Fan, that worries me too 🙏
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Lee_Diehard, good question, not daft at all. Skating matters more than people think. Think of it like doing your books: if your footwork's off, everything downstream is off. A crease-bumper's job is three or four hard steps to cut off the net-front, then a quick pivot back into the rush. If he can't do those steps, Hughes has to wait for him, and that kills the whole point of the pairing.
I tracked zone exits for a stretch a couple seasons back and the pattern was obvious: pairings with a mobile lefty got Hughes the puck facing up ice, pairings with a plodder had him retrieving pucks in his own corner. Small sample though, maybe twenty games, so weigh it how you like. But RobLegend's point stands. Size gets you the crease, feet keep you in the lineup. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Gary's answer covers it, but the part nobody mentions is what happens when the bumper gets pinned low and Hughes is the only one who can carry the puck out. That's the trade you're actually making. Source on any of these slow lefties ever surviving a full season next to an elite mover? I keep asking and nobody's got one.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.