Do the Leafs really deserve 78 points with that goal differential?
299 goals against and people still wanna crown this Leafs team something special, eh? 28th in the league with a differential that ugly, those 78 points are pure smoke and mirrors. Anyone telling me wins hide that defence is a 🤡, I wouldn't touch their puck line with your money, let alone mine 😏
299 goals against and people still wanna crown this Leafs team something special, eh? 28th in the league with a differential that ugly, those 78 points are pure smoke and mirrors. Anyone telling me wins hide that defence…
Smoke and mirrors? Points are points, 32 wins don't come from luck. Ugly differential, sure, but you call 28th a failure while they're still collecting results.
299 against hurts yeah, but 32 wins don't fall off a truck 🤬 through thick and thin, I've seen worse Leaf teams get bailed out by one hot goalie night, this group grinds 💪
On the terraces since I was a kid.
YUL99 has a point buried in there, I'll give him that. A minus-46 differential alongside 78 points usually screams unsustainable, and 299 against is genuinely ugly. But 32 wins and 14 more results beyond regulation across 82 games isn't smoke, that's a team winning tight ones. Small sample caution goes the other way too, one season tells you direction, nothing more. I'd worry about the defence before I'd call the points fake. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Back in my day we watched the old barns on a fuzzy TV and nobody counted goal differential, they just counted losses. I sat through some rotten seasons here in Alberta, Battle of Alberta nights where the Flames couldn't keep the puck out of their own net either, and I'll tell you what the old boys at the rink used to say. Bad defence shows up every single year, bad luck doesn't last 82 games.
So when I see 299 against and 253 for, I side more with YUL99 than the youngsters here. 32 wins in tight games is a skill, sure, Kev_Fan makes that point fair enough. But watch as long as I have and you'll get it, teams that bleed goals like that don't stay lucky two springs running. The points are real this year. Whether they mean anything next year, that's the question 😉
@KevReds this, 100%. My old man said the same, wins are wins no matter how ya count em 🔥 If we take points off the Leafs for ugly diff, half the league loses em too tbh
Pulled my own spreadsheet on this one before posting, because half the arguments here are talking past each other. The numbers say both things at once: 32 wins and 14 results beyond regulation over 82 games is real skill in tight games, but a minus-46 differential with 299 against usually regresses hard. Small sample caveats apply all season long, one campaign is barely a dataset, still the historical pattern leans toward YUL99 on this one. Kev_Fan called it fairly, that those wins weren't smoke, just expensive. My honest answer is I don't know which direction they break next October, and anyone claiming certainty from 82 games of weirdness is selling something. The Nashville game on the 6th gives us a first read, then Vegas and Colorado away tell us more about that defence than any table ever will. I'm keeping the verdict open until the puck actually drops.
I keep my own tables 📊