Are the Leafs a bottom-five team now, or is 28th place just noise?
28th place with 299 goals against in your own barn isn't noise, that's a resignation letter π Core Four era died somewhere around Christmas and nobody in Toronto noticed because the fanboys were too busy waiting for next season. If they drop four of those first five in October I'm smashing the over on Dubas apologists melting down π€‘πΈ
It's a lottery, not sport.
28th place with 299 goals against in your own barn isn't noise, that's a resignation letter π Core Four era died somewhere around Christmas and nobody in Toronto noticed because the fanboys were too busy waiting for nextβ¦
One bad season and you're writing the eulogy. Vegas, Colorado and Utah in four days is a brutal October stretch, so I'd hold the funeral until the Buffalo game on the 15th.
Where's the proof?
No eulogy from me tbh, one ugly season and Amy's already tossing dirt π€ yeah 299 against at home is gross but Vegas and Colorado back to back in October says squat about the Core Four, we all knew that stretch was a meat grinder before the schedule dropped. Beat Nashville on the 6th and watch this thread flip real quick π₯πͺ
I keep a spreadsheet on these guys and even I flinched at 299 against in your own rink. Amy's got the stronger case here, Harry, because a minus-46 goal diff over 82 games doesn't hide in small sample territory, that's a full season telling you the defence is cooked. That said, Buffalo at home on the 15th is the real tell, since Vegas and Colorado will beat half the league. If they drop the winnable ones against Nashville and the Sabres, then I'll bring the shovel myself.
some folks get a bit worked up about the standings this early on, but have you seen this much cyclical garbage before? those wild slumps feel big when you're watching them week to week, but it's not the end of the world until the season is over, just like back when we watched the Leafs struggle through a couple of rebuilding years when the barns felt a bit grittier. take the long view, the structure still has life in it.
Remember when the grass was greener π±
Ben_Ultra, receipts please on the spreadsheet, because minus-46 over 82 games is the one number here that can't be spun. The October schedule gives them Nashville and Buffalo at home, both winnable, with Vegas, Colorado and Utah stuffed in between. Survive that 3-2 or better and I might concede the season was noise. Anything less and I'll believe the Core Four era needs a rebuild.
Where's the proof?
Fair question from Mike, and the receipts are simple: 299 against at Scotiabank over 82 games is a season-long verdict on the defence, no sample size excuse there. My only hesitation is that one bad year doesn't kill a core, so I'd want to see how they come out of the Nashville and Buffalo home games before writing the eulogy. If the Vegas and Colorado trips pile up losses too, then Amy's got a real case.
I keep my own tables π